Importance of Particle Tracking and Calculating the Mean-Squared Displacement in Distinguishing Nanopropulsion from Other Processes

Abstract

In this paper we show that processes such as Brownian motion, convection, sedimentation, and bacterial contamination can cause small particles to move through liquids in a fashion which may be mistaken as nanopropulsion. It is shown that particle tracking and subsequent statistical analysis is essential to ascertain if small particles actually propel themselves, or if they are propelled by another process. Specifically we find that it is necessary to calculate the mean-squared displacement of particles at both short and long time intervals, to show that the direction of propulsion changes coincident with rotation of the particle by Brownian motion, as this allows nanopropulsion to be differentiated from Brownian motion, convection and sedimentation. We also find that bacteria can attach themselves to particles and cause them to be propelled. This leads to motion which appears very similar to nanopropulsion and cannot be differentiated using particle tracking and therefore find that carefully designed control experiments must be performed. Finally, we suggest an experimental protocol which can be used to investigate the motion of small objects and prove if they move due to nanopropulsion.

Velocity Fluctuations in Helical Propulsion: How Small Can a Propeller Be

“…This is due to the presence of multiple degrees of freedom, which can cause the helical structure to undergo translational and rotational diffusion 22 along and about various symmetry axes, which in turn raises the question regarding which particular diffusion is of highest importance. 23 This has been elaborated on in greater detail later in this Letter. Apart from Pe, we have also considered a quantity termed as "directionality", 24 which provides a quantitative estimate of the deviation of the propeller from its intended path.…”

Guiding microscale swimmers using teardrop-shaped posts

“…The velocity of each rod is measured from its particle track using the mean squared displacement [33], using tracks observed over a minimum of 100 frames, at a frame rate of 10 fps. In typical experiments using glass wafers, a wide distribution of rod speeds is observed.…”

A Pickering Emulsion Route to Swimming Active Janus Colloids

“…To test the effectiveness of the chemically prepared active colloids, we benchmark catalytic activity, propulsion velocity, and rotational rate against equivalent conventionally PVD manufactured Janus particles 35. In addition, we compare batches of chemically prepared colloids with varying concentrations of platinum salt added during the seed growth stage of the protocol.…”