In discourse: Bourdieu’s theory of practice and habitus in the context of a communication‐oriented nursing interaction model

Abstract

Aims. This paper presents a discussion on the potential of the theories of practice and habitus as espoused by the sociologist Bourdieu. Background. The interaction between nurses and patients is a constitutive element in the nursing process and a central aspect in the theories developed by Paterson and Zderad, and Orlando. Bourdieu¢s theory of habitus and practices assists in understanding and explaining differentiated results concerning nurse-patient interaction. Data sources. In a study on interactions with paraplegic patients, distinguished levels of interactions, which show considerable diversity among one another, could be identified. The data were collected over a period of 20 months in 2004-2006. The results present the central topics of interaction and show that understandingoriented interaction is rare. Discussion. Communicative acting in nursing always takes place in a social context. In the interaction with patients, nurses assign a higher distinctive value to the standardized concepts of care facilities than to the actually perceived need of care. An understanding-oriented interaction assumes that the nurses with their own contributions, themes and authorities, prove themselves in the eyes of the patient. It is expected from nurses that they habitualize their own concepts so that they can be represented in a convincing manner. Conclusion. If an understanding-oriented interaction is to extend into the practice of nursing, it is of crucial importance that both interaction partners assure each other how and with what capital their interaction is to be realized. Nurses need professional habitus to become agents in the social field of health.

Mutuality in health care: review, concept analysis and ways forward

“…If the mutuality of the nurse and client remains solely within the ‘intimate niche’ of the I‐thou relationship ‘it will have no relevance to other agents in the therapeutic process’ (Sieger et al . , p. 487). To support families towards increased well‐being, nurses need a way of thinking about social relations and their impact upon health.…”

Social meanings and understandings in patient-nurse interaction in the community practice setting: a grounded theory study

“…It is the case that medical encounters and work [3,9,33,35] and patient-nurse encounters and interaction [1-5] have been subject to some examination. However, the perspective of patients is under examined in relation to understanding and acceptance of their role [12,18,19]. As contributing evidence, patients and nurses in this study experienced some uncertainty in striving to make sense of the challenges of the changing health service, including roles and expectations.…”

Teaching Communication to Nursing Students: Contemporary Perspectives on Practice

“…Qualitative studies to explore client and family needs and experiences would also be very useful, and the importance of this type of research to inform practice needs to be emphasized. While low in the hierarchy of evidence [21,22], these types of studies are particularly useful for understandings client/family experiences and informing both local and general practice and their increased inclusion [8] in top quality peer reviewed journals such as the Journal of Advanced Nursing indicate their growing value. Learning from recent problems with poor care delivery would indicate that a preoccupation with statistics and trends while at the same time not listening to the patient voice can have detrimental consequences [5], thus establishing a place for both qualitative research evidence and other sources of patient testimony (audits, complaints) in both teaching approaches and practice initiatives is crucial.…”

“…A multiplicity of reasons exist for this, however it is thought that nurses perhaps may un aware of the impact of their communication on the client [6], but it is very clear from testimony just how important even simple elements of communication are to patients and families [7]. The literature suggests that client's interaction with nursing staff can be stress provoking [8], and the impact of poor communication can be pervasive and longlasting [6]. Recently the Nursing Standard Journal partnered with the Patients Association (UK) developing a campaign in response to the current need to improve standards of care.…”