Incentive structure in team-based learning: graded versus ungraded Group Application exercises

Abstract

Purpose:Previous studies on team-based learning (TBL) in medical education demonstrated improved learner engagement, learner satisfaction, and academic performance; however, a paucity of information exists on modifications of the incentive structure of “traditional” TBL practices. The current study investigates the impact of modification to conventional Group Application exercises by examining student preference and student perceptions of TBL outcomes when Group Application exercises are excluded from TBL grades.Methods:During the 2009–2010 and 2010–2011 academic years, 175 students (95.6% response rate) completed a 22-item multiple choice survey followed by 3 open response questions at the end of their second year of medical school. These students had participated in a TBL supplemented preclinical curriculum with graded Group Application exercises during year one and ungraded Group Application exercises during year two of medical school.Results:Chi-square analyses showed significant differences between grading categories for general assessment of TBL, participation and communication, intra-team discussion, inter-team discussion, student perceptions of their own effort and development of teamwork skills. Furthermore, 83.8% of students polled prefer ungraded Group Application exercises with only 7.2% preferring graded and 9.0% indicating no preference.Conclusion:The use of ungraded Group Application exercises appears to be a successful modification of TBL, making it more “student-friendly” while maintaining the goals of active learning and development of teamwork skills.

The use of team-based learning in a second year undergraduate pre-registration nursing course on evidence-informed decision making

“…A second issue was around the value of the ungraded application activities. This has also been reported in the literature, and a recent review highlighted that grading or ungrading application activities did not influence overall student performance but graded activities clearly added to students' anxiety levels (Deardorff et al 2014). These more negative perceptions of team-based learning emphasise the importance of ensuring students are well prepared for the requirements of team-based learning, and in particular how to use the study resources.…”

Introducing the Team Based Learning as an Approach to Reviving Interest in Biochemistry amongst Undergraduate Medical Students-An Exploratory Study

“…Numerous studies have shown the benefits of this mode of active learning as a powerful tool to ingrain in-depth knowledge and increase comprehension of the topic (12,13). Vasan in his study on TBL in Anatomy and Embryology concluded such sessions improve student commitment towards course content.…”

A Novel Grading Strategy for Team‐Based Learning Exercises in a Hands‐on Course in Molecular Biology for Senior Undergraduate Underrepresented Students in Medicine Resulted in Stronger Student Performance

“…The incentive structure for TBL is a critical component of the learning process and has being the subject of many recent studies . For instance, some authors have suggested that ungraded TBL application exercises could be more student‐friendly while still supporting an active learning environment that fosters development of teamwork skills . Nevertheless, ungraded RATs have been shown to be associated with poor TBL performance as compared to graded RATs .…”