Indonesia’s Trade Diplomacy Through FTA: Analysis on Actors, Processes, and Goals of Diplomacy

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to examine the various FTAs that Indonesia has been involved in within the last 15 years by looking at the three core elements of trade diplomacy: actors, processes, and goals of FTAs. Based on these elements, this research finds that Indonesia’s FTA diplomacy tends to be dominated by foreign policy interests compared to economic ones, which can be observed through several elements. First, Indonesia’s FTA diplomacy is dominated by state actors and foreign policy players with little involvement from economic players and non-state actors. The numerous FTAs signed through ASEAN also reinforced this domination since ASEAN’s distribution of authority placed foreign policy players at a higher hierarchy than trade actors. Second, Indonesia’s FTA diplomacy tends to be inefficient and ineffective due to dualism in its diplomatic process, which involves collective negotiations through ASEAN and at the same time, individually through the national government. This resulted in a multiplicity of agreements, leading to the low number of FTA utilisation by private sectors. Third, Indonesia’s continued use of ASEAN as a medium for FTA negotiations leads to the strengthening of foreign policy goals relative to economic ones, due to ASEAN’s internal characteristics which focuses more on political-security relations, rather than economic ones. Based on these observations, Indonesia needs to reposition its FTA diplomacy to find a better balance between its foreign policy and trade goals.

The Role and Significance of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) in the Modern Asia-Pacific Region

“…With only four bilateral trade agreements in 2001, the Asia-Pacific saw a massive increase in 10+ years, totaling 54 bilateral trade agreements by 2015 and 55 agreements with extra-regional economies (Solís and Wilson, 2017). However, towards the mid-2000s, there were efforts to consolidate these agreements through mega-regional free trade agreements (FTAs); two of the most well-known were the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) (Killian, 2020). The TPP was initiated in 2005 and was later signed as a Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) in 2018, while the RCEP negotiations began in 2011 and were finalized in 2020.…”

Indonesia’s Economic Diplomacy in the Context of the EU’s Palm Oil Embargo: Reaching Out to Turkey as an Alternative Market

“…The Indonesian Ministry of Trade is a negotiator in developing free trade rules. The Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs was the primary negotiator (Killian, 2021). Furthermore, the Indonesian government must be able to maximize economic diplomacy tools like free trade agreements to market its commodities abroad.…”