The strength growth of a bitumen emulsion-based cold in-place recycling asphalt mixture (BE-CIR) is time-dependent and time-consuming due to the addition of water. There is a great difference between the curing conditions of specification in the laboratory and the in situ conditions, which often leads to a great discrepancy between the results of lab specimens and the field cores. The main objective of this paper is to evaluate the curing effect on laboratory BE-CIR considering field-water evaporation and heat-transfer conditions. Four different curing methods were designed by using different combinations of waterproof layers, heat insulation layers, and variable temperature modes. The variations in temperature indexes, moisture content, air void, and indirect tensile strength (ITS) with curing time were tested, and the mutual influence of these indicators was analyzed. Furthermore, the results of the laboratory samples were compared with the field cores. Testing results show that the performance of the BE-CIR mixture is significantly different from that with no treatment, which is manifested as higher moisture content and lower air void and ITS under the same curing time. The internal temperature of the mixture is the main factor affecting the variation of moisture content, especially on the first curing day. The air void of the mixture has a strong linear relationship with the moisture content. Moisture content and ITS under different curing methods showed similar trends and could be divided into two stages. Taking the field cores as a benchmark, it can be concluded that the field-water evaporation condition should be considered in the setting of indoor curing methods, while the heat transfer could not.