Influence of Size, Shape, and Flexibility on Bacterial Passage through Micropore Membrane Filters

Abstract

Sterilization of fluids by means of microfiltration is commonly applied in research laboratories as well as in pharmaceutical and industrial processes. Sterile micropore filters are subject to microbiological validation, where Brevundimonas diminuta is used as a standard test organism. However, several recent reports on the ubiquitous presence of filterable bacteria in aquatic environments have cast doubt on the accuracy and validity of the standard filter-testing method. Six different bacterial species of various sizes and shapes (Hylemonella gracilis, Escherichia coli, Sphingopyxis alaskensis, Vibrio cholerae, Legionella pneumophila, and B. diminuta) were tested for their filterability through sterile micropore filters. In all cases, the slender spirillum-shaped Hylemonella gracilis cells showed a superior ability to pass through sterile membrane filters. Our results provide solid evidence that the overall shape (including flexibility), instead of biovolume, is the determining factor for the filterability of bacteria, whereas cultivation conditions also play a crucial role. Furthermore, the filtration volume has a more important effect on the passage percentage in comparison with other technical variables tested (including flux and filter material). Based on our findings, we recommend a re-evaluation of the grading system for sterile filters, and suggest that the species Hylemonella should be considered as an alternative filter-testing organism for the quality assessment of micropore filters.

Wastewater-Based Epidemiology of Cocaine in the Brazilian Federal District: Spatial Distribution, Weekly Variation and Sample Preservation Strategies

“…The same authors also evidenced a shape-dependent bacterial selection during the filtration process. 52 Also, preservation by acidification leads to low relative errors on the concentration of COC and BE, as can be seen in Figure 2, probably by the inhibition of chemical and/or biological degradation mechanisms. We believe that the preservation procedure based on filtration followed by acidification implied in lower analyte losses in comparison with other filtration-based strategies due to the inhibition caused by the low pH.…”

Isolation and characterization of low nucleic acid (LNA)-content bacteria

“…The cell volume of the individual bacterial cell was calculated based on the measurements from cryo-TEM pictures (Equation 3, Wang et al, 2008) on the principle of a rod-shaped particle with spherical ends.…”

Enrichment and Detection of Escherichia coli O157:H7 from Water Samples Using an Antibody Modified Microfluidic Chip

“…Previously, Wang et al . evaluated the performance of these types of membrane filters with pore sizes ranging from 0.1 to 0.45 μm to determine the effect of cell shape and size on bacterial filterability and determined that bacterial shape, rather than their absolute size, was a key factor in determining cell recovery 23. We recovered 92 ±5% (n = 4) of E. coli O157:H7 microbial material using the 0.1 μm.…”