Influences of size and sex on invasive species aggression and native species vulnerability: a case for modern regression techniques

Abstract

Animal behaviour is of fundamental importance but is often overlooked in biological invasion research. A problem with such studies is that they may add pressure to already threatened species and subject vulnerable individuals to increased risk. One solution is to obtain the maximum possible information from the generated data using a variety of statistical techniques, instead of solely using simple versions of linear regression or generalized linear models as is customary. Here, we exemplify and compare the use of modern regression techniques which have very different conceptual backgrounds and aims (negative binomial models, zero-inflated regression, and expectile regression), and which have rarely been applied to behavioural data in biological invasion studies. We show that our data display overdispersion, which is frequent in ecological and behavioural data, and that conventional statistical methods such as Poisson generalized linear models are inadequate in this case. Expectile regression is similar to quantile regression and allows the estimation of functional relationships between variables for all portions of a probability distribution and is thus well suited for modelling boundaries in polygonal relationships or cases with heterogeneous variances which are frequent in behavioural data. We applied various statistical techniques to aggression in invasive mosquitofish, Gambusia holbrooki, and the concomitant vulnerability of native toothcarp, Aphanius iberus, in relation to individual size and sex. We found that medium sized male G. holbrooki carry out the majority of aggressive acts and that smaller and medium size A. iberus are most vulnerable. Of the regression techniques used, only negative binomial models and zero-inflated and expectile Poisson regressions revealed these relationshipsThis research was supported by a Marie Curie International Reintegration Grant within the 7th European Community Framework Programme (KM). Additional support was provided by the Spanish Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (project CGL2013-43822-R), the University of Girona (project SING12/09), the Government of Catalonia (ref. 2014 SGR 484), and the European Commission (COST Action TD1209

Unstable intraguild predation causes establishment failure of a globally invasive species

“…The 20-minute observation period began 30 s after the screened divider was removed. The number of fin nips (including attempted nips) and chases (rapid chasing followed by a response by the pursued animal) were observed on all four mosquitofish or sailfin mollies and all four guppies (Thompson et al 2012, Magellan andGarc ıa-Berthou 2015). The observer was able to see all animals in the tank.…”

Prioritizing Sex Recognition Over Learned Species Recognition: Hierarchical Mate Recognition in an Invasive Fish

“…As toothcarp 2 (T2) received no or very few mating attempts (see section "Results") this data set was excluded from analyses and only the mating attempts received by T1 and M1 were included. For these analyses we used Generalized Estimating Equations (GEEs), an extension of Generalized Linear Models developed for situations where response variables are nonindependent, to account for the within-subjects factors (e.g., Magellan and García-Berthou, 2015). For all analyses, fish group was the experimental unit (i.e., the two toothcarp and two mosquitofish that were examined together) and the dependent variable, frequency of mating attempts received, was analyzed with Poisson distribution and a log-link function.…”

Innate responses to conspecific and heterospecific alarm cues in the endangered eastern cape redfin Pseudobarbus afer

“…The activity of redfins without any external stimuli was examined to establish normal redfin behaviour patterns. Only the pre‐stimuli observation data were used in a generalised estimating equation (GEE; an extension of generalised linear models for use when dependent variables are related rather than independent: Magellan & García‐Berthou, ). Behaviour type (in refugia, motionless and movement) was the within‐subjects independent factor and time spent performing each behaviour (normal distribution and identity‐link function) as the dependent factor.…”