Informal Sector Tax Administration in Zimbabwe

Abstract

SUMMARY Governments have to raise revenue to finance public goods. This study analyses the challenges that Zimbabwe, like most developing countries, faces in attempting to collect taxes from its informal sector. Because the so‐called informal sector forms a large and sometimes growing component of the economy, collecting sufficient revenues to fund expenditure requires tax authorities to seek ways to collect revenues from those earning their incomes in the informal sector. There has been an attempt to collect taxes from the informal sector in Zimbabwe over the past 8 years. Although the actual amount collected from this sector has increased, an evaluation of the way taxes are administered needs to go beyond the amount of revenue collected. It needs to also look at issues such as the proportion of the informal sector paying these taxes, the amount collected as a proportion of total revenues, the costs incurred in collecting these taxes and the tax administration's ability to encourage quasi‐voluntary compliance. This study indicates that the levels of evasion (confirmed by the informal sector associations themselves), selective application of tax regulations and corruption are alarmingly high. These factors, together with the very high tax rates and sheer ignorance, operate as a serious disincentive in informal sector tax compliance resulting in very low revenues from this sector. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Tax Administration and Entrepreneurial Performance: A Study of SMEs in Uganda

“…In addition, the World Economic Forum (2016) indicates that border administration in Uganda is not transparent, has a lot of irregular payments and the clearance process is inefficient. Moreover, the main problem facing tax authorities in African countries in tax administration is corruption (Dube, 2014).…”

Informal sector taxes and equity: Evidence from presumptive taxation in Zimbabwe

“…15 The design of presumptive taxes in Zimbabwe was informed by research carried out by ZIMRA from 2003 to 2005, but only on the profitability of the informal urban transport sector and, even in this case, it is not clear that the Ministry of Finance took heed of the results. According to one ZIMRA official, a lump sum, equivalent to a tax rate of 18% on profit, 16 instead of the prevailing company income tax (CIT) rate of 30% in 2005, was recommended on "fairness grounds": 12 A brief description of the presumptive tax system in Zimbabwe is provided here as background to the equity analysis; more detail on the design and implementation can be found in Dube (2014). 13 Inflation in Zimbabwe after dollarization of the economy in 2009 has been very low, with an average annual rate of 2.2% between 2011 and 2014 (ZIMSTAT, 2015, p. 14).…”

“… In earlier work (Dube, ), the legal and administrative features of the informal sector tax system in Zimbabwe were described. In this article we focus on the equity implications. …”

“… A brief description of the presumptive tax system in Zimbabwe is provided here as background to the equity analysis; more detail on the design and implementation can be found in Dube (). …”

“…Here, the term 'informal economy' refers to unregistered enterprises (the informal sector) as well as those who are informally employed in both the formal and informal sectors(ILO, 2013).2 In earlier work(Dube, 2014), the legal and administrative features of the informal sector tax system in Zimbabwe were described. In this article we focus on the equity implications.…”