Initial Characterization of Novice Engineering Designers' Consideration of Contextual Factors

Abstract

Engineering designers are encouraged to consider relevant contextual factors throughout their design processes. However, specific practices for incorporating context into design processes are lacking in the existing literature, and curricula related to the use of context during design processes is limited. As a preliminary step toward characterizing novice engineering designers' use of contextual factors, we qualitatively coded 10 mechanical engineering capstone design reports for contextual factors; half of the projects had domestic sponsors with varying themes, and the other half of the projects had international sponsors with a global health theme. Our findings showed that teams considered technological and institutional factors most frequently; other factors were considered less frequently. Global health themed design teams considered more contextual factors than non-global health themed teams. There was considerable variability among the contextual factors considered, as well as the stages during which they were considered. These outcomes have the potential to inform the development of pedagogical tools to support the acquisition of skills related to formally addressing context during engineering design processes.

The Effects of Scenarios on Decision-Making Quality in Early Design – An Empirical Study

“…In that sense, scenarios may help them to grasp the impacts and uncertainty related to the task at hand. This is substantiated by previous research, as Burleson et al (2021) show that support for gathering qualitative context information related to design tasks can be particularly useful for novices, and less so for experts. Therefore, scenarios (which are shown to have their greatest impact in context-understanding) may be especially helpful for novices.…”

Thinking Beyond the Device: An Overview of Human- and Equity-Centered Approaches for Health Technology Design

“…For example, they engaged a broad range of stakeholders to understand context, and they visited and revisited contextual information, adjusting the scope of their projects, even to the point of terminating a project, based on the contextual information they gathered and analyzed. However, studies have demonstrated that engineering students consider and incorporate contextual factors in much more narrow ways, focusing on technical considerations to a far greater extent than broader social considerations (39,43,44). It is important to note, however, that students' desire to incorporate broader social considerations has been shown to exceed the course structure and tools provided to them (21).…”

Co-Creation in Contextual Competences for Sustainability: Teaching for Sustainability, Student Interaction and Extracurricular Engagement

“…The Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology (ABET) states in its Student Outcomes that students must consider the impact of engineering solutions in the environment to make informed judgments [7]. The ABET criteria ensure that engineering graduates develop nontechnical skills while deepening their understanding of the context [8]. This helps to cultivate responsible engineering professionals of the future.…”