“…There are data on the effects of PAR (instantaneous flux and daylength), temperature, carbon dioxide and oxygen, generally in pairs, on the rate of photosynthesis and, in some cases, growth in organisms lacking CCMs (Salvucci and Bowes, 1981;Maberly, 1985a,b;Johnston et al, 1992;Maberly et al, 1992;Kübler and Raven, 1996a;Kübler et al, 1999;Sherlock and Raven, 2001;Raven et al, 2005a;Maberly et al, 2009). It must be borne in mind that the distinction between aquatic organisms with and without CCMs is not as clear as that between C 3 and C 4 terrestrial plants, and the 'intermediate' organisms are not readily assigned to a category like the (admittedly heterogeneous) assemblage of C 3 -C 4 intermediate terrestrial vascular plants (Salvucci and Bowes, 1981;Sherlock and Raven, 2001;Raven et al, 2005a;Maberly et al, 2009).…”