“…Relatively few studies have examined early reproductive stages of external fertilizers under OA, and among those that have, most have focused on in vitro fertilization assays, or on sperm swimming behavior (due to the well-documented importance of intracellular pH for sperm function; Nishigaki et al, 2014). Results from these investigations have so far been mixed; some studies have reported negative effects of OA on sperm motility (e.g., Campbell, Levitan, Hosken, & Lewis, 2016;Morita et al, 2010;Nakamura & Morita, 2012;Schlegel, Havenhand, Gillings, & Williamson, 2012;Vihtakari et al, 2013) while others have revealed negligible or even positive effects (Caldwell et al, 2011;Eads, Kennington, & Evans, 2016;Graham et al, 2016;Havenhand & Schlegel, 2009). Furthermore, there are inconsistent associations between OA-induced changes in sperm motility and in vitro fertilization rates (reviewed in Byrne, 2011;Ross, Parker, O'Connor, & Bailey, 2011), and thus, the fitness consequences of the effects of OA on gametes remain elusive.…”