Interfaith Marriage in Islam: Classical Islamic Resources and Contemporary Debates on Muslim Women’s Interfaith Marriages

Abstract

In Islamic tradition, both Muslim men and women are prohibited from marrying mushriks and are required to marry only other believers. However, Muslim scholars’ definitions of ‘believers’ and ‘mushriks’ differ for men and women. Whereas kitabī (Jewish and Christian) women are accepted as believers, not mushriks; kitabī men, who believe in the same religion as kitabī women, are not accepted as believers. Thus, there is a prohibition of Muslim women marrying men of different faiths in Islam. This prohibition is mainly based on the consensus of scholars, which is mostly derived from the cultural and social understanding of marriage and gender roles in the family rather than strictly from religious sources of reference. The aim of this article is to discuss how classical and contemporary Muslim scholars have approached the question of Muslim women’s interfaith marriages in Islam. Classical Muslim scholars did not consider the changing circumstances in their society and reconsider the religious rule regarding Muslim women’s interfaith marriages, as they did for Muslim men’s interfaith marriages. On the other hand, some contemporary Muslim scholars argue that the absence of any explicit prohibition in the Qurʾān indicates that Islam leaves the decision regarding whom to marry up to the Muslim woman and that she should consider her conditions and her prospective husband’s attitude toward her religious faith before making the decision for herself.

Fostering Islamic Personality Students through The Role of Islamic Religious Education Teachers

“…A good teacher's personality will have a memorable impression on students. Islamic religious education and habituation will foster a person's attitude and personality to carry out Islam's teachings and behave well in his daily life (Elmali-Karakaya, 2022).…”

The Dynamic Landscape of Interfaith Marriage in Indonesia: Navigating The Supreme Court Circular Letter (SEMA) No. 02 of 2023 and Population Administration Law

“…Nonetheless, divergent interpretations of Qur'anic scripture have precipitated scholarly discourse and debate among theologians and religious scholars (Elmali-Karakaya, 2022). Central to this scholarly controversy is the interpretative nuances surrounding the designation of "people of the book" (Nasir, 2022) as delineated in three distinct verses of the Qur'an, namely Surah Al-Maidah verse 5, Surah Al-Baqarah verse 221, and Surah Al-Mumtahanah verse 10 (Jannah & Hadi Imawan, 2023).…”

Analisis Pernikahan Beda Agama tentang Pandangan Hukum Positif Agama dan Sosiologi

“…Di masyarakat agama Hindu di Indonesia tidak mengenal yang nama nya pernikahan perbedaan agama perkawinan beda agama memang di kenal di masyarakat hindu India tapi tidak berlaku untuk di Indonesia. Dan di agama Khong hucu juga menyebutkan bahwa tidak di perbolehkan kamu menikah dengan pria ataupun wanita yang berbeda keyakinan nya dengan mu sebab itu peneguhanmu kepada tuhanmu (Elmali-Karakaya, 2022). Maka dari itu tidak ada hukum agama yang memperbolehkan pernikahan beda agama karena itu sangat tabu dalam kalangan pemuka agama di indonesia ketika adanya pernikahan beda agama maka harus ada salah satu dari mempelai pria ataupun wanita yang harus rela meningalkan agama nya umtuk melangsungkan pernikahan.…”