Interrogating Social Sustainability in the Biofuels Sector in Latin America: Tensions Between Global Standards and Local Experiences in Mexico, Brazil, and Colombia

Abstract

Across the Americas, biofuels production systems are diverse due to geographic conditions, historical patterns of land tenure, different land use patterns, government policy frameworks, and relations between the national state and civil society, all of which shape the role that biofuels play in individual nations. Although many national governments throughout the Americas continue to incentivize growth of the biofuels industry, one key challenge for biofuels sustainability has been concern about its social impacts. In this article, we discuss some of the key social issues and tensions related to the recent expansion of biofuels production in Mexico, Colombia, and Brazil. We argue that a process of "simplification" of ecological and cultural diversity has aided the expansion of the biofuels frontier in these countries, but is also undermining their viability. We consider the ability of governments and non-state actors in multi-stakeholder initiatives (MSI) to address social and environmental concerns that affect rural livelihoods as a result of biofuels expansion. We analyze the tensions between global sustainability standards, national level policies for biofuels development, and local level impacts and visions of sustainability. We find that both government and MSI efforts to address sustainability concerns have limited impact, and recommend greater incorporation of local needs and expertise to improve governance.

Pathways for a Brazilian biobased economy: towards optimal utilization of biomass

“…The International Labour Organization (ILO) noticed that ‘forced labor’ is still an issue, and the burning of cane can cause health problems, although the recent mechanization of sugarcane cultivation ensured a decrease of the number of employees working under tough conditions . Land ownership is also a problem as Brazil is sensitive to land grabbing by (international) agro‐industrials, which threatens small‐scale farmers and indigenous communities . Recently, however, international organizations have expended great effort to include all of these social issues in certification schemes for biobased products, ensuring improvements in social conditions with a growing demand for biobased products …”

Understanding the Implications of Alternative Bioenergy Crops to Support Smallholder Farmers in Brazil

“…It is the interactions between these three actors that largely shape the evolution of institutions and policies aimed at spurring investment [82]. In the case of sugarcane in Brazil, such interactions have paved the way for the current model of large-scale agro-industrial development, with the consequent "radical transformation of natural ecosystems, local customs, and social relationships" [83] (p. 1321). Such approaches have resulted in local actors being marginalized and local knowledge being excluded from decision-making processes related to regional development, leading to a lack of recognition and procedural justice.…”

Biofuel research: perceptions of power and transition

“…Studies demonstrate that the expansion of biofuels in countries of the Global South was only possible through the partial neglect (simplification) of their cultural and ecological diversity [57]. Nygren [58] illustrates how leading retailers, in negotiation with environmental organizations, have guided consumers' expectations of certified Southern forest products by building images of Southern community forest producers as authentic and exotic others.…”