Genetic evidence predicts a causative role for amyloid- (A) in Alzheimer's disease. Recent debate has focused on whether fibrils (amyloid) or soluble oligomers of A are the active species that contribute to neurodegeneration and dementia. We developed two aggregation protocols for the consistent production of stable oligomeric or fibrillar preparations of A-(1-42). Here we report that oligomers inhibit neuronal viability 10-fold more than fibrils and ϳ40-fold more than unaggregated peptide, with oligomeric A-(1-42)-induced inhibition significant at 10 nM. Under A-(1-42) oligomer-and fibril-forming conditions, A-(1-40) remains predominantly as unassembled monomer and had significantly less effect on neuronal viability than preparations of A-(1-42). We applied the aggregation protocols developed for wild type A-(1-42) to A-(1-42) with the Dutch (E22Q) or Arctic (E22G) mutations. Oligomeric preparations of the mutations exhibited extensive protofibril and fibril formation, respectively, but were not consistently different from wild type A-(1-42) in terms of inhibition of neuronal viability. However, fibrillar preparations of the mutants appeared larger and induced significantly more inhibition of neuronal viability than wild type A-(1-42) fibril preparations. These data demonstrate that protocols developed to produce oligomeric and fibrillar A-(1-42) are useful in distinguishing the structural and functional differences between A-(1-42) and A-(1-40) and genetic mutations of A-(1-42).
Amyloid- (A)1 is derived by the proteolytic processing of amyloid precursor protein (APP), resulting in a peptide predominantly 40 or 42 amino acids in length. Mutations in APP and the presenilins that increase the amount of A-(1-42) cause AD (for review, see Ref. 1). Historically, the "amyloid cascade" hypothesis has defined the fibrillization of A into amyloid deposits, a pathologic hallmark of AD, as a toxic gain of function (2). That A-(1-42) is more fibrillogenic than A-(1-40) fits well with this hypothesis. However, amyloid plaques do not always correlate in number, tempo, or distribution with neurodegeneration or clinical dementia. Thus, recent debate within the AD community has focused on whether fibrillar (amyloid) or soluble oligomers of A are the active species of the peptide that ultimately cause the synaptic loss and dementia associated with AD (3-7). In vivo, small, stable oligomers of A-(1-42) have been isolated from brain, plasma, and cerebrospinal fluid (8 -10) and correlate with the severity of neurodegeneration in AD (11, 12). Thus, although genetic evidence predicts that A is a causative factor in AD, the role of fibrillar and oligomeric A in the pathogenesis of AD remains unclear.Initial in vitro studies suggested that A-induced neurotoxicity required the peptide to adopt a fibrillar aggregation state, with unaggregated peptide at low doses actually exhibiting neurotrophic effects (13)(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)). Recent studies demonstrate that non-fibrillar structures, including oligomers and ...