Is the Internet a Reliable Source for Dietary Recommendations for Stone Formers?

Abstract

Purpose Kidney stone formation is influenced by environmental factors, especially diet. Certain dietary modifications, including increased fluid intake, reduced animal protein and sodium consumption, and normal calcium intake, reduce the risk of stone activity. Patients frequently use the Internet for information regarding disease processes. We undertook this study to determine the quality of dietary stone information available in this communication domain. Methods The Google search engine was used to survey 458 consecutive sites related to kidney stones and dietary information. The presence or absence of the four aforementioned dietary recommendations was recorded. The sites were analyzed for correctness, information on all four domains present and correct; inaccuracy, something mentioned about all four areas but ≥1 recommendation error(s); deficiency, information on ≤3 or domains and no recommendation errors; deficiency and inaccuracy, information on ≤3 areas and ≥1 recommendation error(s). Results Web sites Correct 80 (17.4%) Inaccuracy 10 (2.2%) Deficiency 365 (79.5%) Deficiency/inaccuracy 3 (0.7%) Total 460 There were 10 errors regarding calcium intake and 2 pertaining to protein consumption. The quality of information varied with the reporting source. Conclusions Internet-based information regarding four important dietary modifications for kidney stone formers is frequently incomplete. Dietary inaccuracy, while uncommon in this communication domain, is mostly centered on the misconception that calcium restriction is beneficial. The quality of dietary information may depend on the Internet information source.

Dietary Intake of Fiber, Fruit and Vegetables Decreases the Risk of Incident Kidney Stones in Women: A Women’s Health Initiative Report

“…The nuances of which vegetables are high in oxalate can be confusing, and information from medical providers or internet sources are often incomplete, and thus patients may be globally reducing vegetable intake in an attempt to reduce their oxalate intake. 27 Reassuringly, this study specifically found no increased risk of stone formation with higher vegetable intake. Previous studies of fiber, fruit and vegetable intake have been mixed, 5, 6, 9, 11-17 possibly in part due to a failure to stratify based on stone history.…”

Information Technology and Lifestyle: A Systematic Evaluation of Internet and Mobile Interventions for Improving Diet, Physical Activity, Obesity, Tobacco, and Alcohol Use

“…For example, the US National Physical Activity Plan includes media strategies that encourage stakeholders to incorporate such emerging technologies into programs 32. The US Community Preventive Services Task Force recently recommended use of a computer‐based Electronic Screening and Brief Intervention (e‐SBI) for addressing excess alcohol 33. Yet, considering the strength of the evidence, our findings suggest that the application and testing of novel information and communication technologies should be greatly expanded.…”

Twenty-five years of idiopathic calcium nephrolithiasis: has anything changed?

“…It has been demonstrated that only 17% of all web sites on kidney stone disease do provide scientifically correct information, while the other 83% give deficient or inaccurate advices [29]. The most common mistake is promoting a dietary calcium restriction, which in turn has been demonstrated to be useless or even harmful many years ago [10,11,17].…”