Islamophobia, Muslimophobia or racism? Parliamentary discourses on Islam and Muslims in debates on the minaret ban in Switzerland

Abstract

There is currently no clarity on what Islamophobia covers: Does it relate to hostility towards Islam, hostility towards Muslims or racism against Muslims? While some argue that the term Muslimophobia should replace Islamophobia due to the hostility being directed at Muslims as people, rather than Islam the religion, it is not clear whether this is the case in practice. This article examines expressions of Islamophobia and Muslimophobia and their relationship to racism in Swiss parliamentary debates on banning the construction of minarets in Switzerland. It demonstrates that Islamophobia and Muslimophobia are different from each other but mostly occur in tandem. Furthermore, Muslimophobia can be but is not always a form of racism due to the 'manipulation of culture' in which proponents of the ban can de-essentialise, as well as essentialise, cultural traits to argue that Muslims can become integrated if they fulfil certain conditions. Such conditions can, however, be easily manipulated to continually exclude undesirable 'others'. The article contends that the minaret ban initiative relied heavily on the 'slippery slope' fallacy to make both Islamophobic and Muslimophobic arguments, that is, accusing Muslims and Islam of transgressions against Swiss society that have not even occurred.

The Integration of ‘Bottom‐up’ Approaches to the Analysis of Race Talk for the Future of Discourse Analytic Research

“…Beyond positive self‐presentation, Van Dijk () explains how such discourses allow dominant groups to deny the existence of racism, make the public debate about racism seem unnecessary, and allow public opinions to go unchallenged. Since then, a proliferation of researchers has used critical discourse analysis as a theoretical lens to the question of racism and race talk (Cheng, ; Dunn, Pelleri, & Maeder‐Han, ; Essed, ; Parker, ; Poynting, ; Saghaye‐Biria, ; Teo, ).…”

The Relevance of the Centrality and Content of Religiosity for Explaining Islamophobia in Switzerland

“…However, despite the high quantity of research on Islamophobia, research on this subject in Switzerland is still in its infancy. There have been a few studies on the discussion of Islam and Muslims in Switzerland (e.g., Cheng 2015;Behloul 2009;Lindemann and Stolz 2014), but only a very few have focused on Islamophobic attitudes in the country (e.g., Stolz 2005;Berger and Berger 2019). Thus, one reason for the present study is the lack of research on the specific case of Switzerland.…”

The stigma of Muslimness: perceived visibility and racism in daughters of mixed couples with Maghrebian background in Barcelona and Granada

“…Otros autores, aún estando la descripción del hecho racista fundamentada en los mismos parámetros, no lo han denominado racismo cultural, sino "nuevo racismo". Cheng (2015) es un ejemplo del uso de este concepto, y lo denomina así para diferenciarlo del "viejo racismo", aquel sustentado en la diferencia y superioridad biológica entre razas. Cheng (2015) viene a señalar las definiciones de ambos tipos un poco en la misma línea que Modood.…”