Hybrid electrodes containing MoS2 with metals active for the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER) are highly desirable as they can provide a cost‐effective and active route for producing hydrogen. It is well known that the technique used to facilitate such hybrid formation plays a critical role in the activity and stability of the electrode. Here we utilized a novel method for hybridization based on electron‐beam deposition of Ag, Pd, and Mo to make precursor films which, upon sulfurization, formed hybrid electrodes based on vertically aligned molybdenum disulfide (VA‐MoS2). We further modified the surface of these electrodes by exploiting galvanic replacement of palladium. Surprisingly, both hybridization techniques showed a synergistic effect between Pd and Ag, and enhanced activity was enabled by the presence of both metals. XPS, XRD, Raman spectroscopy, and FIB‐EM were used to explore the root cause of the synergy. It appears that enhanced performance is based partially on the mutual solubility of Pd−Ag and the facile diffusion of Ag through the MoS2 film. Ag/VA‐MoS2 modified by galvanic replacement provided 10 mA/cm2 at 210 mV of overpotential and was stable for up to 4000 cycles, surpassing the stability of previously reported Pd/MoS2 hybrids, making these techniques of interest for future generations of hybrid HER electrodes based on MoS2.