Land Allocation Effects of the Global Ethanol Surge: Predictions from the International FAPRI Model

Abstract

We quantify the emergence of biofuel markets and its impact on U.S. and world agriculture for the coming decade using the multi-market, multi-commodity international FAPRI (Food and Agricultural Policy Research Institute) model. The model incorporates the trade-offs between biofuel, feed, and food production and consumption and international feedback effects of the emergence through world commodity prices and trade. We examine land allocation by type of crop, and pasture use for countries growing feedstock for ethanol (corn, sorghum, wheat, sugarcane, and other grains) and major crops competing with feedstock for land resources such as oilseeds. We shock the model with exogenous changes in ethanol demand, first in the United States, then in Brazil, China, the European Union-25, and India, and compute shock multipliers for land allocation decisions for crops and countries of interest. The multipliers show at the margin how sensitive land allocation is to the growing demand for ethanol. Land moves away from major crops and pasture competing for resources with feedstock crops. Because of the high U.S. tariff on ethanol, higher U.S. demand for ethanol translates into a U.S. ethanol production expansion. The latter has global effects on land allocation as higher coarse grain prices transmit worldwide. Changes in U.S. coarse grain prices also affect U.S. wheat and oilseed prices, which are all transmitted to world markets. In contrast, expansion in Brazil ethanol use and production chiefly affects land used for sugarcane production in Brazil and to a lesser extent in other sugar-producing countries, but with small impacts on other land uses in most countries. AbstractWe quantify the emergence of biofuel markets and its impact on U.S. and world agriculture for the coming decade using the multi-market, multi-commodity international FAPRI (Food and Agricultural Policy Research Institute) model. The model incorporates the trade-offs between biofuel, feed, and food production and consumption and international feedback effects of the emergence through world commodity prices and trade. We examine land allocation by type of crop, and pasture use for countries growing feedstock for ethanol (corn, sorghum, wheat, sugarcane, and other grains) and major crops competing with feedstock for land resources such as oilseeds. We shock the model with exogenous changes in ethanol demand, first in the UnitedStates, then in Brazil, China, the European Union-25, and India, and compute shock multipliers for land allocation decisions for crops and countries of interest. The multipliers show at the margin how sensitive land allocation is to the growing demand for ethanol. Land moves away from major crops and pasture competing for resources with feedstock crops. Because of the high U.S. tariff on ethanol, higher U.S. demand for ethanol translates into a U.S. ethanol production expansion. The latter has global effects on land allocation as higher coarse grain prices transmit worldwide. Changes in U.S. coarse grain prices also affect U.S...

The role of irrigation in determining the global land use impacts of biofuels

“…McKinsey & Co. estimate that one-third of the world's population in 2030 will live in basins where the projected gap is greater than 50% [9]. This finding is reinforced by the analysis of global water use in agriculture by Rockström et al [11] who estimate a deficit of 2,500 km 3 of water per year by 2030 in the absence of rainfed area expansion. In summary, it appears that water for agricultural irrigation will become much more expensive in the future -no doubt spurring considerable efficiency gains, but also raising the cost of production and therefore limiting the amount of land on which irrigated crops can be economically grown.…”

“…Such estimated expansion into more carbon-rich land cover such as grasslands or forest is the focus of recent research into the contributions of indirect land use changes (ILUC) to the GHG impacts of biofuels. Many studies have examined the global land use consequences of biofuel production [1][2][3][4][5][6][7]. However, all of these studies have ignored the role of irrigation.…”

“…Several papers discussed the importance of yield response to crop prices and extensive margins [2,6,17,22,23], the market-mediated factors which affect the land use impacts of biofuels [4,15,17,18,21], and the role of international trade and its importance in determining the geographical distribution of land use changes [2][3][4]18,21,24]. The interactions between livestock and biofuel industries and the role of biofuel by-products are another important dimension of this problem and are the focal point of the THT model upon which the current analysis is built.…”

Merging remote sensing data and national agricultural statistics to model change in irrigated agriculture

“…Actually, total corn increased during this period by 0.88 million ha. Prior studies have discussed expansion of corn production related to an increase in corn-based ethanol production (Fabiosa et al, 2009;Wallander et al, 2011). We also infer a connection between the expansion of irrigation across the HPA and increasing demand for corn for ethanol.…”

A strategic framework for improving food security in Arab countries

“…3). Fabiosa et al (2008) suggest that such policies in the USA will probably transmit directly to higher world-market prices for wheat and oilseeds. Sustaining such policies in the future would contribute to thinner wheat markets and an upward structural adjustment in wheat prices.…”