Language and nonlanguage factors in foreign language learning: evidence for the learning condition hypothesis

Abstract

The question of why native and foreign languages are learned with a large performance gap has prompted language researchers to hypothesize that they are subserved by fundamentally different mechanisms. However, this hypothesis may not have taken into account that these languages can be learned under different conditions (e.g., naturalistic vs. classroom settings). With a large sample of 636 third language (L3) learners who learned Chinese and English as their first (L1) and second (L2) languages, the present study examined the association of learning success across L1–L3. We argue that learning conditions may reveal how these languages are associated in terms of learning success. Because these languages were learned under a continuum of naturalistic to classroom conditions from L1 to L3, this sample afforded us a unique opportunity to evaluate the hypothesis that similar learning conditions between languages could be an important driving force determining language learning success. After controlling for nonlanguage factors such as musical background and motivational factors and using a convergence of analytics including the general linear models, the structural equation models, and machine learning, we found that the closer two languages were on the continuum of learning conditions, the stronger their association of learning success. Specifically, we found a significant association between L1 and L2 and between L2 and L3, but not between L1 and L3. Our results suggest that learning conditions may have important implications for the learning success of L1–L3.

True or false? Linguistic and demographic factors influence veracity judgment of COVID-19 rumors

“…Table 1 presents the demographics of participants. Socioeconomic status (SES) scores were calculated based on the fourfactor index of social status specified in Hollingshead (2011) and adapted by Kang et al (2021).…”

A large-scale repository of spoken narratives in French, German and Spanish from Cantonese-speaking learners

“…We encourage researchers to use this database for further analysis and publication. Relevant data have been used in previous publications 36 , 37 .…”

Exploring students’ perception towards teachers’ oral feedback in EFL classroom

“…Due to its widespread use and necessity in many sectors, English has earned the status of "lingua franca" (Kumar, 2020). There is a performance discrepancy between the acquisition of a native language and that of a foreign language, leading scholars in the field of linguistics to hypothesize that the two are served by fundamentally different mechanisms (Kang et al, 2021). (Habok & Magyar, 2018).…”