LCDs are better: Psychophysical and photometric estimates of the temporal characteristics of CRT and LCD monitors

Abstract

Many cognitive and perceptual phenomena, such as iconic memory and temporal integration, require brief displays. A critical requirement is that the image not remain visible after its offset. It is commonly believed that liquid crystal displays (LCD) are unsuitable because of their poor temporal response characteristics relative to cathode-raytube (CRT) screens. Remarkably, no psychophysical estimates of visible persistence are available to verify this belief. A series of experiments in which white stimuli on a black background produced discernible persistence on CRT but not on LCD screens, during both dark-and light-adapted viewing, falsified this belief. Similar estimates using black stimuli on a white background produced no visible persistence on either screen. That said, photometric measurements are available that seem to confirm the poor temporal characteristics of LCD screens, but they were obtained before recent advances in LCD technology. Using current LCD screens, we obtained photometric estimates of rise time far shorter (1-6 ms) than earlier estimates (20-150 ms), and approaching those of CRTs (<1 ms). We conclude that LCDs are preferable to CRTs when visible persistence is a concern, except when black-on-white displays are used.

Psychophysics in a Web browser? Comparing response times collected with JavaScript and Psychophysics Toolbox in a visual search task

“…These are superimposed over the histograms to show the qualitative fit of the model to the distributions of subject-level data. The normal distributions are colored according to the same mapping as in the top part of the figure in experimental setup, such as a change in keyboard, mouse, or monitor (Lagroix, Yanko, & Spalek, 2012;Neath et al, 2011;Plant & Turner, 2009). Thus, we do not view this effect as a major concern, although experimenters should be aware of it.…”

A novel paradigm reveals the role of reentrant visual processes in object substitution masking

“…They were naive psychophysical observers, and had normal or corrected-to-normal vision. The stimuli were presented on a BenQ XL2410T LCD screen, which is known to be free from image persistence (Lagroix, Yanko, & Spalek, 2012). The refresh rate was 120 Hz.…”

Evaluation of tablet computers for visual function assessment

“…However, CRT displays retain some temporal response advantages over LCDs, for displaying moving or flickering stimuli in vision experiments. Therefore, the LCD technology needs careful assessment of its temporal properties (Elze & Tanner, 2012;Wang & Nikolic, 2011), as they have immediate potential as displays for research laboratories (Lagroix, Yanko, & Spalek, 2012), particularly for relatively static displays.…”