Learning Curves in Health Professions Education

Abstract

Learning curves, which graphically show the relationship between learning effort and achievement, are common in published education research but are not often used in day-to-day educational activities. The purpose of this article is to describe the generation and analysis of learning curves and their applicability to health professions education. The authors argue that the time is right for a closer look at using learning curves-given their desirable properties-to inform both self-directed instruction by individuals and education management by instructors.A typical learning curve is made up of a measure of learning (y-axis), a measure of effort (x-axis), and a mathematical linking function. At the individual level, learning curves make manifest a single person's progress towards competence including his/her rate of learning, the inflection point where learning becomes more effortful, and the remaining distance to mastery attainment. At the group level, overlaid learning curves show the full variation of a group of learners' paths through a given learning domain. Specifically, they make overt the difference between time-based and competency-based approaches to instruction. Additionally, instructors can use learning curve information to more accurately target educational resources to those who most require them.The learning curve approach requires a fine-grained collection of data that will not be possible in all educational settings; however, the increased use of an assessment paradigm that explicitly includes effort and its link to individual achievement could result in increased learner engagement and more effective instructional design.

A Novel Curriculum to Optimize Emergency Medicine Residents’ Exposure to Pediatrics

“…Pusic and colleagues have described “experience curves” chronicling the process of knowledge and skill accrual, followed by decay, with return to competence via interval training or experience 21,22. The PEMFU experience fits into a longitudinal PEM framework within our EM residency program intended to minimize this decay.…”

Learning curves in surgery: variables, analysis and applications

“…For group analysis, the group mean and an index of variability are required 29. Group learning curve parameters can be used to guide efficient targeting of educational resources and to determine the most appropriate length of time before revalidation is required.…”

The Journey to Competency-based Medical Education - Implementing Milestones

“…Milestones are importantly grounded in several educational theories of professional development. 1,3,16 Early validity research studies are encouraging in supporting the use of Milestones professional development. [6][7][8][9][10] As a sufficient number of residents graduate and enter practice we will be able to examine the links, or associations, between Milestone performance and quality of practice: the ultimate outcome goal of the Milestone initiative.…”

“…Furthermore, most programs were structured around a time and breadth-based curriculum that struggled to incorporate the concepts of longitudinal professional development and learning curves. 2,3 To help address some of these challenges, the ACGME embarked on the development of Milestones in 2010 after a successful pilot project conducted in Internal Medicine between 2007 to 2009. 4 The Milestones are intentionally designed to help create a developmental language (i.e.…”