With the spread of the notion of sustainability, evaluating alternative roadway design options in terms of economic factors solely has become insufficient, and a need has risen to incorporate environmental and social dimensions. In response to this need, life-cycle evaluation (LCE), which consists of assessing the impacts of certain product/project from cradle to grave, has gained popularity among the pavement community. In its broad sense, LCE encompasses three main evaluation methods that are discussed thoroughly in this paper: life-cycle cost analysis (LCCA), life-cycle assessment (LCA), and social life-cycle assessment (SLCA). An integration of all three LCE methods is known as life-cycle sustainability assessment (LCSA). This paper presents a review of the evolution of LCE through each of these evaluation methods with a focus on pavement methods, applications, and tools. The authors attempt to identify gaps in research and practice of pavement LCE, and to propose enhancements. Incorporating the social dimension of sustainability in pavement LCE and relying on accurate performance prediction and traffic characterization are examples of such improvements. The authors also give suggestions for LCSA scope definition and multi-objective decision making. The paper concludes with recommendations for future research and applications.