Local Perceptions of Climate Change Impacts in St. Kitts (Caribbean Sea) and Malé, Maldives (Indian Ocean)

Abstract

Small Island Developing States (SIDS) are now experiencing the local consequences of a changing climate, environment, and society. Nonetheless, climate change research frequently remains at regional or national levels. Without locally grounded data, islanders’ perceived impacts of the changes might not be considered, thereby causing difficulties when policy and practice responses are implemented without accounting for local understandings. To contribute to addressing this gap, this study examines perceptions of climate change and associated environmental and social changes in two SIDS case studies: St. Kitts in the Caribbean Sea and Malé Atoll, Maldives in the Indian Ocean. Through these two case studies, we assess perceptions of changing social and natural environments through a closed-question, face-to-face survey. Our results suggest that in both island case studies, communities perceive environmental changes to be happening that demand negotiation with the social changes of daily life. Results also suggest that perceived climate change impacts are only part of the equation, as social and economic impacts reveal two case studies of changing island societies. While the geographic context in each case study differs, this study reveals the perceived impacts of climate change and social changes at a local level, providing valuable insights and angles for formulating policies and actions to deal with the myriad of social and environmental changes affecting SIDS.

Awareness of climate change's impacts and motivation to adapt are not enough to drive action: A look of Puerto Rican farmers after Hurricane Maria

“…Farmers in Latin America [ 67 , 68 ], and the Caribbean [ 70 , 71 ] have been noted to lack institutional structures of support. In Puerto Rico, Perfecto and colleagues (2019) found that social capital and support networks were pivotal for Puerto Rican coffee farmers’ recovery after Hurricane María, and that their agroecological practices, such as agroforestry, and other management styles were not sufficient for farms to be resilient and resistant within the catastrophic context of Hurricane Maria [ 54 ].…”

Mangrove Archives: Unravelling Human-environment Interactions from Deeply Buried Deposits at the Site Anse Trabaud, Martinique, Lesser Antilles (1290–780 cal BP)

“…The variable climatic conditions with alternations from dry to wetter periods during the entire Caribbean Ceramic Age, including risk of floods and landslides caused by tropical storms, hurricanes or extreme wave events, would have caused frequent alterations in the coastline and changes in sediment distribution and environmental conditions Divine 2008, 2012;Haviser 2019;Malaizé et al 2011;Rivera-Collazo 2019;Scheffers, Scheffers, and Kelletat 2005). The variable climatic conditions may have impacted indigenous lifestyles over time in terms of water management, foodways and shelter, leading in some cases to settlement reorganisation and abandonment as is still the case nowadays (Beets et al 2006;Cooper 2012;Cooper and Peros 2010;Douglas and Cooper 2020;Hofman and Hoogland 2015;Hofman et al 2014;Samson et al 2015;Stancioff et al 2017Stancioff et al , 2018. The shifts in settlement location recorded for the site of Anse à la Gourde during the various periods of occupation between 1500 and 600 cal BP are a prime example of how the local inhabitants responded to these climatic hazards (Hofman et al 2014).…”

Resilient Caribbean Communities: A Long-Term Perspective on Sustainability and Social Adaptability to Natural Hazards in the Lesser Antilles

“…In the Caribbean Lesser Antilles, deforestation, sand-mining operations, an increase in extreme weather events, and a dependency on tourism with inherently high ecological costs have all produced environmental impacts as well as social change comparable to other regions of the world (e.g., [64][65][66]). These effects have influenced the natural physical protection, local economies, land, homes, fisheries, agriculture, local traditions, and people's heritage [59,[67][68][69]. Mitigation and adaptive planning measures are a top priority to safeguard these coastal environments and livelihoods, and to avoid the further and irreversible loss of the archaeological record and often unwritten histories.…”