This article reports a case of a 40-year-old woman with a history of myelomeningocele and neurogenic urinary incontinence who developed erosion and fistula formation following the placement of an artificial urinary sphincter (AUS) when she was 18 years old. The patient had a long-standing history of urinary incontinence that was unresponsive to prior surgeries for meningomyelocele. She reported the loss of urofecal material from the vagina but did not seek further medical evaluation until the age of 40. Clinical examination revealed protruding tubes from the suprapubic region. The administration of a contrast agent through one of the two tubes led to the visualization of intestinal loops, and the administration of a contrast agent through the urethra confirmed the connection between the rectum, urinary bladder, and vagina. Due to the absence of reliable surgical history and in the absence of abdominal discomfort, bilateral nephrostomies were initially performed to prevent further uro-fecal material loss. The patient showed significant improvement, decided to not seek further evaluation and surgical treatment, and remained socially integrated during the follow-up period of 20 years. This case highlights the severe consequences of AUS placement in a young woman with neurogenic urinary incontinence and emphasizes the importance of proper patient selection and management in the presence of underlying neurological disorders.