Loss of job-related right to healthcare associated with employment turnover: challenges for the Mexican health system

Abstract

BackgroundThe Mexican health system segments access and right to healthcare according to worker position in the labour market. In this contribution we analyse how access and continuity of healthcare gets interrupted by employment turnover in the labour market, including its formal and informal sectors, as experienced by affiliates to the Mexican Institute of Social Security (IMSS) at national level, and of workers with type 2 diabetes (T2DM) in Mexico City.MethodsUsing data from the National Employment and Occupation Survey, 2014, and from IMSS electronic medical records for workers in Mexico City, we estimated annual employment turnover rates to measure the loss of healthcare access due to labour market dynamics. We fitted a binary logistic regression model to analyse the association between sociodemographic variables and employment turnover. Lastly we analysed job-related access to health care in relation to employment turnover events.ResultsAt national level, 38.3% of IMSS affiliates experienced employment turnover at least once, thus losing the right to access to healthcare. The turnover rate for T2DM patients was 22.5%. Employment turnover was more frequent at ages 20–39 (38.6% national level; 28% T2DM) and among the elderly (62.4% national level; 26% T2DM). At the national level, higher educational levels (upper-middle, OR = 0.761; upper, OR = 0.835) and income (5 minimum wages or more, OR = 0.726) were associated with lower turnover. Being single and younger were associated with higher turnover (OR = 1.413). T2DM patients aged 40–59 (OR = 0.655) and with 5 minimum wages or more (OR = 0.401) experienced less turnover. Being a T2DM male patient increased the risk of experiencing turnover (OR = 1.166). Up to 89% of workers losing IMSS affiliation and moving on to other jobs failed to gain job-related access to health services. Only 9% gained access to the federal workers social security institute (ISSSTE).ConclusionsTurnover across labour market sectors is frequently experienced by the workforce in Mexico, worsening among the elderly and the young, and affecting patients with chronic diseases. This situation needs to be prospectively addressed by health system policies that aim to expand the financial health protection during an employment turnover event.

Relationship between burnout and intention to leave amongst clinical nurses: The role of spiritual climate

“…High turnover intention and burnout can have a harmful influence on nursing care, especially on patients' safety. Patient safety is a global issue (Guerra et al, ; Welp, Meier, & Manser, ). The Chinese government is attempting to improve the working conditions for nurses by establishing an special nursing position allowance, increasing the pay for night shift nurses, improving the salary and treatment of front‐line nurses, improving the working conditions of nurses and other measures (China, ).…”

A systematic review of the literature on the impact of the Seguro Popular

“…Overlaps in coverage given labour rotation create multiple duplications and require massive administration to function [ 1 ]. Additionally, given the enormous mobility of workers between formal and informal jobs, the bureaucracy involved in updating their status is a barrier to healthcare [ 2 ]. The configuration of the health system creates inequalities as well.…”

Employment based health financing does not support gender equity in universal health coverage

“…Within a single year women can move between the formal and informal sectors and between employment and unemployment. 23 These changes influence women’s entitlement to high quality healthcare, which consequently affects their health. 24 The same situation has also been documented in South Korea, where women are over-represented in non-standard work.…”

“…More women than men in Mexico become unemployed, and more often. Within a single year women can move between the formal and informal sectors and between employment and unemployment 23. These changes influence women’s entitlement to high quality healthcare, which consequently affects their health 24.…”