Summary Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a developing approach to the treatment of solid tumours which requires the combined action of light and a photosensitizing drug in the presence of adequate levels of molecular oxygen. We have developed a novel series of photosensitizers based on zinc phthalocyanine which are water-soluble and contain neutral (TDEPC), positive (PPC) and negative (TCPC) side-chains. The PDT effects of these sensitizers have been studied in a mouse model bearing the RIF-1 murine fibrosarcoma line studying tumour regrowth delay, phosphate metabolism by magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) and blood flow, using D 2 O uptake and MRS. The two main aims of the study were to determine if MRS measurements made at the time of PDT treatment could potentially be predictive of ultimate PDT efficacy and to assess the effects of sensitizer charge on PDT in this model. It was clearly demonstrated that there is a relationship between MRS measurements during and immediately following PDT and the ultimate effect on the tumour. For all three drugs, tumour regrowth delay was greater with a 1-h time interval between drug and light administration than with a 24-h interval. In both cases, the order of tumour regrowth delay was PPC > TDEPC = TCPC (though the data at 24 h were not statistically significant). Correspondingly, there were greater effects on phosphate metabolism (measured at the time of PDT or soon after) for the 1-h than for the 24-h time interval. Again effects were greatest with the cationic PPC, with the sequence being PPC > TDEPC > TCPC. A parallel sequence was observed for the blood flow effects, demonstrating that reduction in blood flow is an important factor in PDT with these sensitizers. © 1999 Cancer Research Campaign Keywords: photodynamic therapy; magnetic resonance; phthalocyanines
616British Journal of Cancer (1999) 81(4), 616-621 © 1999 Cancer Research Campaign Article no. bjoc.1999 Received 26 November 1998 Revised 22 April 1999 Accepted 26 April 1999 Correspondence to: SB Brown; School of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT, UK This paper was prepared with the full participation of Professor GE Adams, before his death on 6 June 1998. have used the same three sensitizers to assess the effects of charge on PDT efficacy and whether any MRS correlation is itself dependent on the sensitizer charge. As a secondary aim, we have taken advantage of the ability of MRS to measure blood flow immediately following PDT under the same conditions used in the main study, to assess whether reduction in blood flow represents an important mechanism of tumour damage using these sensitizers.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
PhotosensitizersThree phthalocyanines differing in the structure of their constituent side-chains and overall net charge ( Figure 1) were synthesized in the Department of Colour Chemistry, University of Leeds. Tetradihydroxyethylsulphonamide zinc phthalocyanine (TDEPC), Pyridinium methyl zinc phthalocyanine (PPC) and tetracarboxy zinc phthalocyanine (TCPC) have ...