Management accounting change and the changing roles of management accountants: a comparative analysis between dependent and independent organizations

Abstract

Management accounting change and the changing roles of management accountants have dominated both the professional and academic accounting literature in recent years. This paper aims to contribute to these debates by providing evidence from a sample of management accountants working in both dependent (group) and independent (non-group) organizations in the U.K. One thousand (qualified) members of the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (CIMA), U.K., were randomly selected from the association's database for a postal survey questionnaire. In all, 279 professionally qualified management accountants in both types of organizations responded to a postal survey questionnaire (58 percent from dependent and 42 percent from independent organizations respectively). A Mann-Whitney analysis of the responses indicates that while some significant differences exist between the views of the two groups, these management accountants agree on several of the management accounting practices and the roles of the management accountant investigated. The study provides further insight into MAS and the changing roles of management accountants. It was earlier hypothesized that significant differences would exist in the perceptions between the two groups. However the weak support for the hypotheses could be explained by the influence of other institutional forces apart from the head office control which is focused on in the paper. Thus, it was recognized that other institutional forces are likely to be at play in shaping the perceptions of the management accountants. This is a limitation of the paper and future research to study the impacts of other institutional factors is recommended.

Predictors of the Effectiveness of Management Accounting Function in Nigerian Firms

“…As it is crucial for the management accounting function to adequately support the organisation, the management accounting role has growingly advanced with the progression in size and diversity of activities in organisations. In seeking to achieve the aim of aiding managerial functions, the management accounting role is multifaceted, cutting across various functional areas in the organisation (Drury, 2005;Yazdifar and Tsamenyi, 2005;Shank, 2007;Bamber et al, 2008;Mishra, 2011). The multifariousness of the management accounting function is heightened by the many activities undertaken by management accountants such as cost management, treasury, pricing, risk management, internal control, investment appraisal, etcetera (CIMA, 2008;CIMA, 2014;CGMA, 2015).…”

Privatisation and Management Accounting Change: The Drivers of Changes in a Brazilian Electricity Distribution Company

“…Another study investigating change drivers was carried out by Yazdifar and Tsamenyi (2005). The aim of this paper was to understand the process of management accounting change and the changing roles of management accountants in dependent and independent companies.…”

Business Unit Controller Involvement in Management: An Empirical Study in the Netherlands

“…Most of the findings and conclusions of these studies suggest that controllers must focus less on 'number crunching' and become more involved in management decision-making processes (among others: Jablonski et al, 1993;Kaplan, 1995;Cooper, 1996;Lyne & Friedman, 1996;Friedman & Lyne, 1997;Siegel & Sorensen, 1999;Siegel, 2000;Williams, 2000;Colton, 2001;Strikwirda, 2002;Siegel et al, 2003a;2003b;Yazdifar & Tsamenyi, 2005;Vaivio & Kokko, 2006;Järvenpää, 2007). But there are also researchers and management critics who suggest that high controller involvement in management decision processes may not always be desirable (Loomis, 1999;Indjejikian & Matĕjka, 2006).…”