Market reforms and consumption puzzles in China

Abstract

JEL classifications: E21, P24, P36 Key words: transition, consumption, saving, domestic demand, national markets Abstract: China exhibits above average savings and below average consumption as shares of total economic activity when compared with other countries. At the same time, to create more balanced growth at home and rebalance key bilateral trade and capital flow relationships, China's leadership is trying to increase domestic demand. To complement studies that investigate the high rate of savings in China, this study focuses on the variation in consumption as a share of GDP across provinces between 1979 and 2004. Drawing on well-established consumption theories and work done on savings behavior in China, this paper develops an empirical investigation of the variables hypothesized to influence the pattern of consumption across regions.We find that the normal, economic variables have a small explanatory power if significant at all, while the key variables influencing the macro consumption share are structural, and mostly related to government behavior. For example, local government expenditure on health and education is significant and has a relatively large effect on consumption. Consistent with this we also find a positive relationship between consumption shares and the size of the state sector and the share of tax revenue in GDP. We also find some evidence that financial development has a positive effect on consumption shares. Our results suggest that in order for domestic consumption to be increased in the future, new public and private options to replace the declining security and responsibility of the prior state-dominated system will be needed.

Competitiveness in India and China: the FDI puzzle

“…If China can grow without the U.S., in particular, then China can be instrumental in pulling the U.S., and the global economy, out of recession. Much discussion has focused on the need for China to shift to domestic demand as its engine of growth with less reliance on exports, especially after the decline in demand from the developed economies in the wake of the crisis (e.g., Qi and Prime 2009). Official policy in China recognizes this as a goal, and steps have been taken.…”

From internal imbalances to global imbalances: a survey on the causes of China’s export-led growth

“…Kraay, 2000;Kuijs, 2006;Qi and Prime, 2009), doubts remain as to whether the strong rise in income inequality, reported in Section 3, merely reflects higher income uncertainty. Chamon et al (2010, p. 11) report that none of their income measures show evidence of a clear trend in the variance of permanent shocks, while they find a clear upward trend in the variance of transitory shocks.…”

“…Blanchard and Giavazzi, 2006;Qi and Prime, 2009;Baldacci et al, 2010;Barnett and Brooks, 2010;OECD, 2010). Higher government consumption is found to have a positive impact on consumption via three channels: First, through its direct effect; second, through its mediating effect on households precautionary saving (Qi and Prime, 2009;Barnett and Brooks, 2010); and third, through income redistribution to low income households, due to their higher propensity to consume (Baldacci et al, 2010;Yang et al, 2011;Yang 2012). …”

China and India Enter Global Markets: A Review of Comparative Economic Development and Future Prospects

“…One factor accounting for the low consumption in China is that households feel they must save a high proportion of their incomes for education, healthcare and retirement (Qi and Prime, 2009). In China's current transition phase, new options and financial instruments for health insurance and pensions have not yet matured, while the old system of government security has ended.…”