Measuring Multifunctional Agricultural Landscapes

Abstract

Multifunctional agriculture (MFA) has attracted increased attention from academics and policymakers in recent years. Academic researchers have utilised various approaches to assess and measure the multifunctionality of agriculture and rural landscapes. This paper outlines the nature of MFA and key supporting policies, before reviewing the applied research approaches, drawing primarily from the European Union and China where specific policies on MFA have been implemented to support rural development and promote sustainable rural communities. Four distinct types of valuation of modern MFA are recognised: economic, biophysical, socio-cultural, and holistic. Following a search of both the recent and older MFA literature, evaluations of the strengths and weaknesses of quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods applications are provided using examples from a range of recent studies. The review illustrates the diversity of approaches to measure MFA. While noting that many studies operate at a landscape scale, the challenge remains that the lack of commonality in the research approaches applied means it is difficult to provide effective comparisons between studies or to compare findings. A future research agenda will need to emphasise the need for more consideration of the roles of MFA research to support decision-makers, especially policy makers, but also farmers who largely make decisions for individual farms but, if considered collectively, can transform production systems at a landscape scale.

Multi-Scale Features of Regional Poverty and the Impact of Geographic Capital: A Case Study of Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture in Jilin Province, China

“…Farmers engaged in livestock breeding should also be encouraged to expand the scale of their farming into the large areas of mountainous woodlands. In addition, multifunctional agriculture should be developed to increase income and mitigate risks [65]. The transport conditions of the villages should also be improved to strengthen the connection between towns and the economic centers.…”

Pursuing Plurality: Exploring the Synergies and Challenges of Knowledge Co-production in Multifunctional Landscape Design

“…Multifunctionality provides a useful prism for the planning and design of landscapes that are resilient to a variety of socialecological challenges and address the aspirations of a wide variety of stakeholders (Cockburn et al, 2019). Multifunctional landscapes emerge as spaces that address the needs of agricultural production while enhancing vital ecosystem services and serving multiple institutional needs (Song et al, 2020). Additionally, due to the multiple scales that populate landscapes it also helps knowledge producers and managers deal with the limitations of the farm, city, or region.…”

Following Rural Functions to Classify Rural Sites: An Application in Jixi, Anhui Province, China

“…Based on the geographical environment and human characteristics of Jixi, the production function is divided into agricultural production and nonagricultural production; the life function mainly includes cultural inheritance and residential bearing; and the ecological function is mainly based on ecological protection and landscape provision. The indicator selection adopts a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods [31]. Indicators of each function are divided into "state" indicators and "potential" indicators.…”