Measuring the resilience of health systems in low- and middle-income countries: a focus on community resilience

Abstract

The concept of community resilience has gained considerable attention in the global health discussions since the Ebola outbreak of West Africa in 2014–2015. However, there are no measurement models to quantify community resilience. Without measurement models, it is unclear how to test strategies for building community resilience or to describe their likely intended and unintended results and their impact on health outcomes. We propose a measurement model for community resilience with relevant constructs and indicators to measure these constructs. We conducted a scoping review, systematically searching, screening and selecting relevant articles from two bibliographic databases (PUBMED and Google Scholar) for literature using search terms such as “resilience”, “community resilience” and “health systems resilience”. We screened 500 papers, then completed a full text review of 112 identified as relevant based on their title and abstract. A total of 27 papers and reports were retained for analysis. We then aggregated and synthesised the various definitions of community resilience and the frameworks for understanding these definitions. We identified key constructs from these frameworks and organised these constructs into domains and sub-domains. We proposed indicators to capture aspects of these domains and sub-domains and operationalised these indicators as a measurement model for quantifying community resilience in health systems. We propose a model with 20 indicators to assess community resilience. These indicators tap into various constructs from different theoretical frameworks of community resilience and are useful for assessing the level of knowledge, financial resources, and human, social and physical capital that are needed (or lacking) to respond to any types of shock, including health shock at the community level. This is an initial attempt to describe a multilevel measurement model for quantifying community resilience. This model will help to guide the development and testing of strategies for strengthening community resilience and will require further work to assess its relevance, reliability and validity in different LMIC settings.

Are Pandemics Gender Neutral? Women's Health and COVID-19

“…In low-and-middle-income-countries (LMICs), as in West Africa, health systems are overburdened and resilience against outbreaks is low ( 35 , 36 ). This is characterized by inaccessible healthcare service, lack of support for a diverse population, and challenges with identifying and isolating health threats while maintaining its core functions.…”

Assessing Response Readiness to Health Emergencies: A Spatial Evaluation of Health and Socio-Economic Justice in Pakistan

“…The improved sanitation is also helpful in recycling the water as reported by the World Health Organization ( www.who.int ). Bhandari & Alonge, ( 2020 ) HS5 Sustainable access to improved water + Percentage of population who has access to an improved (sustainable) drinking water. The improved water here refers to piped water, hand pump, water motor\tube well, covered well, or filtration plant.…”

Exploring Two Decades of Research in Community Resilience: A Content Analysis Across the International Literature

“…23 From the perspective of the health system, Bhandari and Alonge defined CR as a process of linking a set of network adaptability (resources with dynamic attributes) at the individual or community level with the function of the health system at the community level after a health shock and the positive trajectory of adaptation. 24 Based on diverse perspectives, we can conclude that CR is a proactive process, not a passive response. 25,26 For the framework and dimension of CR, many efforts have been done in the previous research.…”