Silicon carbide (SiC) formed through pyrolysis of preceramic polymers loaded with SiC particles has gained significant attention for applications such as coatings, composite matrix modifications, and most importantly additive manufacturing. This work presents combined synchrotron XRD, Raman spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, nano-indentation, and Vickers indentation of pyrolysis bonded SiC to shed light on the changes of composition and mechanical properties of these materials. Characterization was performed on samples that were heat treated ranging from the synthesis 850 °C up to 1500 °C. Pre-treatments of the powders prior to pellet synthesis, such as heat treatment and etching using a hydrofluoric acid (HF), were investigated. It is shown that the degradation of mechanical properties when exposed to higher temperatures is due to the burnout of amorphous carbon clusters remnant of the pyrolysis process of the preceramic polymer. Furthermore, prior HF etching and removal of the native oxide layer of the powders showed improved density and hardness values in the final pellets. The average Vickers hardness of the control samples were 4.59 GPa and later 3.74 GPa when exposed to 1500 °C, while the samples synthesized using powders that were etched with HF had an average hardness value of 9.37 GPa and later 6.86 GPa when exposed to 1500 °C.