Medical students and controversial ethical issues: results from the multicenter study SBRAME

Abstract

BackgroundMedical students(MS) will face ethical issues throughout their lives as doctors. The present study aims to investigate medical students’ opinions on controversial ethical issues and factors associated with these opinions.MethodsSBRAME (Spirituality and Brazilian Medical Education) is a multicenter study involving 12 Brazilian medical schools with 5950 MS. Participants completed a questionnaire that collected information on socio-demographic data, medical schools characteristics, religious beliefs and opinions on controversial ethical issues. Of all MS, 3630 participated in the survey (61.0%).ResultsThe sample was 53.8% women and the mean age was 22.5 years. In general, most MS have no objections to prescription of birth control (90.8%), adult stem cell use (87.5%), embryonic stem cell use (82.0%) and abortion for genetic reasons (51.2%). Approximately half of students have no objections to human cloning (47.3%), 45.7% to withdrawal of artificial life support, 41.4% to euthanasia and 23.3% to abortion for failed contraception. Socio-demographic data such as age, gender and income had little influence on MS opinions. On the other hand, medical schools characteristics (number of medical students in the university, year of medical school foundation, location of the university and type of university) and religious aspects (religious affiliation, religious attendance, non-organizational religiousness and intrinsic religiousness) were highly correlated with their opinions. In general, MS with more supportive opinions on controversial ethical issues were less religious and from non-traditional (newer), urban, public and bigger universities.ConclusionThe current study reveals MS have different opinions regarding controversial ethical issues. Noteworthy, these opinions seem to be shaped more by university characteristics and religious beliefs than socio-demographic data.

Does Decision-making in End-of-life Care Differ Between Graduating Medical Students and Experienced Physicians?

“…Thus, these issues should be included in both undergraduate and postgraduate education in palliative medicine. In a Brazilian study, 46% of medical students did not object to withdrawing artificial life support (23), while 75% of the medical students were willing to withdraw mechanical ventilation in our study. The variability among countries regarding the withdrawal of mechanical ventilation probably explains this difference (24).…”

“…Although the palliative care approach in this scenario could be regarded as obvious, our result shows that medical schools in Finland seem to offer a basic understanding of EOL-care. In Western Europe, attitudes towards euthanasia and PAS have become more accepting among the public and, to a lesser extent, among physicians and medical students (5,13,23,26). In our study, the students considered euthanasia and assisted suicide less reprehensible than the GPs.…”

Concepções Sobre Espiritualidade: Programas De Provimento De Médicos No Cariri Cearense

“…Não obstante, em outro estudo semelhante 13 , evidenciou-se que os estudantes de medicina sentem medo em impor suas crenças religiosas às pessoas ao tentarem abordar a espiritualidade, pois ainda encontram dificuldade em dissociar espiritualidade de religiosidade, muitas vezes atribuindo a definição de uma a outra.…”

Ethical aspects of the stem cells' use as healthcare technologies in personalized medicine

“…1 trebe matičnih ćelija kao ravnopravne zdravstvene tehnologije u sistem zdravstvene zaštite, odnosno sa povećanjem starosti se smanjuje stepen slaganja sa tvrdnjom da je veoma značajno da terapija u svrhu radikalnog produženja života bude obuhvaćena sistemom zdravstvene zaštite, što se i poklapa sa rezultatima ispitivanja homogenosti godine studija prema slaganju sa navedenom izjavom. Dodatno, u studija koja se bavila kontroverznim etičkim pitanjima, između ostalog i matičnim ćelijama, sprovedena na sličnom uzorku mladih ljudi sa 12 medicinskih fakulteta u Brazilu, pokazano je da 87,5 % i 82,0% od ukupnog broja studenata medicine (3630, 2908, respektivno) nema ništa protiv upotrebe adultnih i embrionalnih matičnih ćelija [13]. Potrebno je naglasiti da ovo istraživanje ima i određena ograničenje, a pre svega to je upotreba dizajna studije preseka, gde se ne može dokazati uzročno-posledična veza.…”