Mental Health Service Users’ Perceptions of Stigma, From the General Population and From Mental Health Professionals in Mexico: A Qualitative Study

Abstract

Negative attitudes towards people with mental health disorders have been widely studied and identified in the general population, and even within health care professionals. Moreover, studies focused on service users have also identified mental health professionals, including psychiatrists, as a source of stigma. However, in Mexico and Latin America few studies have been conducted addressing this issue. To explore mental health service users' perceptions of stigma by members of the general population and by psychiatrists in Mexico, service users at a psychiatric hospital in Mexico were invited to participate in either focus groups or individual interviews, which were audio recorded, transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis. A total of 47 service users participated in this study. The results suggested that participants were not only aware of the possible consequences of mental health related stigma, but they have also experienced stigmatisation for having a mental illness. Participants also considered psychiatrists can hold negative attitudes towards people with mental illness, something that can represent a barrier for them to have optimal quality of care. Therefore, participants agreed that these attitudes should be addressed to improve the care they received from these professionals. This study suggests that, like members of the general population, psychiatrists are also considered as a source of stigma by people with mental illness in Mexico. These findings not only add to previous work conducted in Mexico and other countries, they also confirm the importance of addressing negative attitudes in this group of health professionals.

Depression and suicidal ideation in Mexican medical students during COVID-19 outbreak. A longitudinal study

“…Therefore, future studies should (Ho et al, 2020;Husain et al, 2020a, b). Mexico is a middle-income country with a relatively high incidence of mental disorders (Medina-Mora et al, 2003), where a low proportion of the population seeks mental health care and even fewer receive treatment (Heinze et al, 2019;Lagunes-Cordoba et al, 2021). Today, the issue of psychiatric illness continues to be stigmatized by our society, especially among doctors and medical students where the proportion of medical students with depression seeking treatment is very low (Puthran et al, 2016).…”

Assessment of dropout rates in the preclinical years and contributing factors: a study on one Thai medical school

“…One important factor includes negative attitude or stigma, which is frequent among medical students [ 42 ]. Several studies found stigma to be a strong barrier to reach mental health services not only medical students but also all general mental health service users [ 43 – 47 ]. Stigma reduction is challenging, for the most effective way is still disputable [ 48 , 49 ].…”

Estudio Exploratorio De Preferencias Y Barreras De Atención Para La Salud Mental en Universitarios

“…Sin embargo, los participantes reconocen sus problemas de salud mental e incluso cómo repercuten en su vida cotidiana, en sus contextos y de manera personal, principalmente en lo afectivo, que coincide con el estudio de Berenzon et al (2014) al encontrar que las principales causas son las preocupaciones y la sensación de malestar emocional. Por tanto, los pocos universitarios que acuden a servicios de salud mental, son principalmente porque ya identifican un problema grave emocional y/o conductual, en este sentido, esta investigación encontró que hay universitarios con diagnósticos de ansiedad y depresión, trastornos de personalidad, y manifestaciones de tristeza, desesperanza, irritabilidad, soledad, y problemas familiares, económicos y sociales (Lagunes-Cordoba et al, 2020).…”