With the advent of this new journal, one is drawn to ask, what should be different about "the scholarship of teaching and learning" in health promotion from other fields and from the past of health education? Professors in health education and health promotion carry a burden of teaching responsibility, similar to those teaching medical, nursing, dental, and other health professions, to bring their experience from practice to the classroom, and their students into the settings of practice for learning experiences. Other distinguished professions, such as law and engineering, require clerkships and apprenticeships. With the rapid growth of academic programs for Master of Public Health (MPH) and other graduate degrees in health promotion, and even more rapid for undergraduate courses and new baccalaureate degrees, faculty have had to be recruited directly from their own graduate training with little or no experience in the field before being thrust before classrooms of inexperienced students. Sometimes the classrooms include students with more experience than their faculty. Similarly, their research as faculty members needs to be informed by firsthand and periodic exposure to the problems, practice, and political circumstances that give rise to the research questions and that present the realities in which the results of their research would be applied. The proposed concept here of "turnstile career" captures this need for periodic immersion (back and forth) as we journey through our teaching, research, practice, policy, and service positions and responsibilities.