The behaviour of gap states due to coordination defects (eg dangling bonds) and metal induced gap states (MIGS) are compared using density functional supercell calculations. Whilst both types of gap states cause carrier recombination, they are passivated in different ways. Defects can be passivated by shifting their states out of the gap, whereas MIGS lie on normally coordinated atoms and their states cannot be shifted. Their 'passivation' requires the insertion of an insulating layer to attenuate them sufficiently before they enter the semiconductor. We show that MIGS also cause Fermi level pinning, inhibiting the control of work function by the contacts, and so they must also be attenuated to enable certain solar cell designs. Recombination losses at the contacts are now a major factor limiting Si solar cell efficiencies [1]. This leads to a focus on contact passivation and thus it is critical to understand the behaviour of the gap states causing recombination. At the same time, especially for Si, there is a desire to reduce production costs, for example by using lower processing temperatures or lower quality Si [2,3]. An example is a trend to define carrier-selective contacts not by doping but by introducing contacts of unusually high or low work function. Both of these aspects require a clear understanding of the passivation of gap states in PV devices and their interfaces.