“…(Markovich et al, 2019;Condon et al, 2020). Studies that provide some constraint on the depth of active circulation are reviewed by Manning and Caine (2007), Welch and Allen (2014), and Markovich et al (2019), and can be broadly categorized into three types: (1) studies using hydraulic, chemical, and environmental tracer (mainly groundwater age) data from tunnels and mines (e.g., Mayo et al, 2003;Marechal and Etchevery, 2003;Tomanaga et al, 2017); 2studies using geothermometry and temperature data from open boreholes and springs, along with coupled heat and fluid flow modeling (e.g., Sanz and Yelamos, 1998;Saar and Manga, 2004;Manning and Caine, 2007;Frisbee et al, 2017); and (3) studies using surface geophysical surveys, in some cases coupled with borehole geophysical and fracture data (e.g., Robinson et al, 1974;McClymont et al, 2012;St. Clair et al, 2015;Flinchum et al, 2018;.…”