Early detection of recurrent cervical cancer is important to improve survival rates. The aim of this study was to explore the clinical performance of DNA methylation markers and high‐risk human papillomavirus (HPV) in cervicovaginal self‐samples and urine for the detection of recurrent cervical cancer. Cervical cancer patients without recurrence (n = 47) collected cervicovaginal self‐samples and urine pre‐ and posttreatment. Additionally, 20 patients with recurrent cervical cancer collected cervicovaginal self‐samples and urine at time of recurrence. All samples were self‐collected at home and tested for DNA methylation and high‐risk HPV DNA by PCR. In patients without recurrent cervical cancer, DNA methylation levels decreased 2‐years posttreatment compared to pretreatment in cervicovaginal self‐samples (p < .0001) and urine (p < .0001). DNA methylation positivity in cervicovaginal self‐samples was more frequently observed in patients with recurrence (77.8%) than in patients without recurrence 2‐years posttreatment (25.5%; p = .0004). Also in urine, DNA methylation positivity was more frequently observed in patients with recurrence (65%) compared to those without recurrence (35.6%; p = .038). Similarly, high‐risk HPV positivity in both cervicovaginal self‐samples and urine was more frequent (52.6% and 55%, respectively) in patients with recurrence compared to patients without recurrence (14.9% and 8.5%, respectively) (p = .004 and p = .0001). In conclusion, this study shows the potential of posttreatment monitoring of cervical cancer patients for recurrence by DNA methylation and high‐risk HPV testing in cervicovaginal and urine samples collected at home. The highest recurrence detection rate was achieved by DNA methylation testing in cervicovaginal self‐samples, detecting 77.8% of all recurrences and, specifically, 100% of the local recurrences.