Metropolitan anxieties: a critical appraisal of Sartre’s theory of colonialism

Abstract

Within postcolonial studies there is now a well-established wariness of the Eurocentric or metrocentric tendencies of postcolonial theory itself. For some the charge that postcolonial theory continues to interpret the history and culture of non-European societies through European frames of reference can be traced to the provocative theory of colonisation developed by French philosopher, novelist and political activist Jean-Paul Sartre. We subject Sartre's theory of colonialism to critical scrutiny and question this claim. We locate Sartre's philosophical works and political activism against the backdrop of a twentieth-century Parisian intellectual life marked by fierce struggles over the future of Marxism. Sartre's metrocentricism was tempered by his tortuous efforts to write existentialism into the Marxist canon, a theoretical endeavour that led him to replace Marxism's eschatology and linear teleology with a series of circular histories based on the complex ways in which separate anti-colonial movements spiral off following their own contingent, creolised and anarchic trajectories. Sartre's desire to contest and rethink rather than submit to and seal metrocentric framings of colonialism and anticolonialism derived from his weddedness to a historicised phenomenology of existence as spatial. Critical interrogation of the complicity of postcolonial theory in the global march of metrocentric ontology affords both geography and postcolonial studies a new impetus for dialogue. Any project that aspires to a transcendence of metropolitan modes of knowing must first better understand the situated production and complexities of such modes of knowing. Before scrutinising how the colonising tendencies of postcolonial theory might best be handled, there is a need to map historical geographies of the different theoretical projects and practices that have emerged in different metropolitan locations and at different times. key wordsSartre colonialism postcolonialism existentialism Marxism spatiality metrocentricism

Spiders, Sartre and ‘magical geographies’: the emotional transformation of space

“…Andrews 2007; Davidson 2003a; LeBlanc 2011); on the other, we add to existing critiques of Sartre’s rather conspicuous absence in the geography literature writ large (e.g. Boyle 2005; Boyle and Kobayashi in press; Davidson 2003b), arguing that Sartre’s work holds potential (if not pre‐figurative) import for geographers concerned to theorise affective space. In particular, we suggest that the pre‐reflective consciousness Sartre associates with emotions may anticipate the way that ‘affect’ has come to be described by proponents of non‐representational theory (NRT), albeit with some distinctions.…”

“…But Sartre was never just an ‘existentialist’. He was one of the most innovative philosophers of the 20th century, a novelist, playwright, literary critic, biographer, political activist and founding editor of the radical journal Les Temps Modernes , a public intellectual with a profound interest in psychoanalysis, an unorthodox humanist, and for much of his life a communist who developed a radical critique of racism and colonialism (on the latter, see Boyle and Kobayashi 2011). To be sure, following the end of the Second World War, he sometimes seemed too willing to place his thinking in the service of the rigid institutional Marxism of the Parti Communiste Français and, as Hayman remarks, ‘even his philosophical pronouncements were liable to be adulterated by Realpolitik ’ (1987, 16).…”

Traditional Wisdom and Modern Knowledge for the Earth’s Future

“…As such, this paper represents a much wider conversation in/outside the discipline (see among others Pickles 2004 ;McFarlane 2006 ;Escobar 2007 ;Hooper and Kramsch 2007 ;Anderson 2008 ;Boyle and Kobayashi 2011 ;Lester 2012 ). 1 In the paper I lay out three ways in which Other knowledges about "environments/territories"-two concepts at the heart of geographical disciplinary endeavour-are incorporated into the geographical canon, and the work they do there.…”

In the face of epistemic injustices?: on the meaning of people-led war crimes tribunals

“…A central theme in Sartre's later writings is the idea that human praxis is always and everywhere dialectical, spatial, geographically situated, and constituent of actual human history (see Boyle and Kobayashi, 2011;Kobayashi and Boyle, 2014). Sartre sought to extend this insight by casting ethics as human praxis (theory in action) in given historical and geographical conditions.…”