Millennial-scale change on a Caribbean reef system that experiences hypoxia

Abstract

Coastal hypoxia has become an increasingly acknowledged threat to coral reefs that is potentially intensifying because of increased input of anthropogenic nutrients. Almirante Bay (Caribbean Panama) is a semi-enclosed system that experiences hypoxia in deeper waters which occasionally expand into shallow coral reefs, suffocating most aerobic benthic life. To explore the long-term history of reefs in the bay we extracted reef matrix cores from two reefs that today experience contrasting patterns of oxygenation. We constructed a 1800-year-long record of gastropod assemblages and isotope compositions from six U-Th chronologically-constrained reef matrix cores. We extracted two cores from each reef at 3 m water depth and two additional cores from a deeper part (4.8 m) of the hypoxia-exposed reef. Results show that the deeper part of the hypoxic reef slowed in growth and stopped accreting approximately 1500 years BP while the shallow part of the reef continued to accrete to the present day, in agreement with a model of expanding hypoxia at this time. Our proxy-based approach suggests that differences among these palaeoindicators in the two reefs may have been driven by an increase in hypoxia via eutrophication caused by either natural changes or human impacts. Similar patterns of increasing herbivores and decreasing carbon isotope values occurred in the shallow part of the hypoxic reef during the last few decades. This suggests that hypoxia may be expanding to depths as shallow as 3 m and that shallow reefs are experiencing greater risk due to increased human activity.

Fossil dermal denticles reveal the preexploitation baseline of a Caribbean coral reef shark community

“…The Bocas del Toro region has experienced major environmental and ecological changes since the beginning of the 20th century, stemming from agriculture, land clearing, and coastal development (59). Benthic habitats across the archipelago have undergone dramatic transformations, including shifts in the dominant reef builders as well as decreased coral cover, due to deteriorating water quality, disease, bleaching, deep water hypoxia, and hydrological change (22,27,35,37,60)-a pattern of degradation documented across the greater Caribbean (13,61). These anthropogenic disturbances, in turn, could have degraded habitat for both sharks and their prey, in addition to lowering prey nutritional quality (62).…”