Mining in the Newspapers: Local and Regional Media Representations of Mineral Exploration and Mining in Finland, Germany, and Spain

Abstract

The understanding of public debates over mineral exploration and mining largely originates from exceptional situations such as mining accidents of conflicts. Less is known about how mining is portrayed and understood under more conventional settings. What storylines dominate the local day-to-day public debate? This article presents results from a comparative case study focusing on newspaper coverage of mineral exploration and mining in three European countries representing different geological and socio-economic contexts. Newspaper articles from the Geyer-Erzgebirge region in Germany, the Andalusia region in Spain, and Northern Finland are studied. The sample looks into the period between September 2018 and February 2020 and shows that regional newspapers report about mining issues relatively intensively even in the absence of major accidents or other media events causing peaks of attention. The tone of the articles is generally neutral to positive towards mining activities, reflecting the specific local settings, historical experiences, and future expectations. Despite the different contexts of the three countries, there were considerable similarities to the topics highlighted, including common themes of mining revival, mining events and social interaction, history of mining, and damages related to mining. Past, present, and future employment opportunities related directly or indirectly to the mining sector are key storylines. Another recurrent underlying theme is the need to balance environment and safety risks and socio-economic prosperity, typically covered through ordinary disputes among the mining sector, public authorities, regional non-governmental organizations, and local initiatives.

Storylines nailing or failing sustainability: Energy, mining and mobility as narrative arenas for societal transition

“…The plot of the green mining storyline stresses the inevitable need for new mines providing materials essential for energy transition, and possibilities introduced by novel and responsible exploration and mining technologies (Lyytimäki, Benighaus, et al, 2021). These aspects were present also in the Talvivaara case.…”

“…A major leak from a gypsum waste pond caused severe water pollution in 2012 and subsequent environmental management failures intensified the debate (Sairinen et al, 2017) The Talvivaara case exemplifies several key aspects of the mining debate, including trustworthiness of the promises of mining companies and public skepticism, adequacy of environmental risk management schemes and effectiveness of activities of public authorities, and the tension between domestic and foreign actors. Wrongdoings and accidents of this single mine contributed to the erosion of social licence to operate and casted the whole mining sector as villains (Eerola, 2022;Lyytimäki, Benighaus, et al, 2021). Attempts to rebuild trust on the promises of green mining include both company-level communications and a network governance approach supported by the state aiming to bring diverse stakeholders together (Lesser, 2021).…”

The Strengthening Government Policies on Mineral and Coal Mining to Achieve Environmental Sustainability in Indonesia, Africa and Germany

“…UBA also provides advice to the government regarding sustainable environmental and nature conservation policies; Local Government Institutions are local government institutions responsible for supervising mining activities and management of mineral resources in their respective areas; The German Mining Industry Association is the organization representing the mining industry in Germany, including mining companies, mining equipment manufacturers and related service providers. The German Mining Industry Association plays a role in promoting sustainable mining activities in Germany and contributes to the development of technology and innovation to ensure responsible and sustainable mining operations 54 .…”

Journalists from Local Media in Sibiu (Romania) and the Challenges of Goal 11 from UN Agenda2030

“…"The communication industry is dominated by big multimedia corporate groups, coexisting with fast-growing independent digital newspapers." (Lyytimäki et al, 2021). Although the dominant media model in Europe is the liberal one, the mainstream media picture in Romania can be characterized in similar terms.…”