Modeling hydrogen networks for future energy systems: A comparison of linear and nonlinear approaches

Abstract

Common energy system models that integrate hydrogen transport in pipelines typically simplify fluid flow models and reduce the network size in order to achieve solutions quickly. This contribution analyzes two different types of pipeline network topologies (namely, star and tree networks) and two different fluid flow models (linear and nonlinear) for a given hydrogen capacity scenario of electrical reconversion in Germany to analyze the impact of these simplifications. For each network topology, robust demand and supply scenarios are generated. The results show that a simplified topology, as well as the consideration of detailed fluid flow, could heavily influence the total pipeline investment costs. For the given capacity scenario, an overall cost reduction of the pipeline costs of 37% is observed for the star network with linear cost compared to the tree network with nonlinear fluid flow. The impact of these improvements regarding the total electricity reconversion costs has led to a cost reduction of 1.4%, which is fairly small. Therefore, the integration of nonlinearities into energy system optimization models is not recommended due to their high computational burden. However, the applied method for generating robust demand and supply scenarios improved the credibility and robustness of the network topology, while the simplified fluid flow consideration can lead to infeasibilities. Thus, we suggest the utilization of the nonlinear model for postprocessing to prove the feasibility of the results and strengthen their credibility, while retaining the computational performance of linear modeling.

A Review of Optimal Design for Large-Scale Micro-Irrigation Pipe Network Systems

“…Nonlinear programming plays a crucial role in addressing a wide range of practical engineering problems. It is mainly used in energy supply systems [59,60] (such as natural gas [61][62][63], petroleum, electricity, etc.) and pipeline water distribution systems [64][65][66] (such as urban and rural water distribution networks and water supply networks).…”

Powering Europe with North Sea offshore wind: The impact of hydrogen investments on grid infrastructure and power prices

“…optimizing the hydrogen transmission or distribution networks such as [13] who developed an approach for designing a hydrogen pipeline network, and [14] who used designed a hydrogen pipeline network in Germany using GIS. Furthermore, [15] compared the modelling of hydrogen pipelines with linear and non-linear approaches, finding that linear approaches are largely appropriate, but that their solutions should be checked for feasibility. Other papers have focused on optimizing the entire supply chain, including production, storage and transport.…”

Towards a resilient and cost-competitive clean hydrogen economy: the future is green

“…Nevertheless, it has been shown that the more detailed project-based modelling of transport infrastructure entails a negligible cost difference compared to the induced computational burden. 71 A potential future research would be the assessment of limited installation rates for the green hydrogen production facilities. The results, however, might lead to higher investments in blue hydrogen supply facilities that might become stranded assets in the long run.…”