“…The oxygen isotopic ratio ( δ 18 O) in terrestrial archives such as ice cores, speleothems and tree rings, is typically interpreted as a proxy of past rainfall and/or temperature based on a local regression model or “calibration” [e.g., Hendy and Wilson , 1968; Jouzel et al , 1997; Treble et al , 2005a; Danis et al , 2006; Lachniet and Patterson , 2006; Liebminger et al , 2006]. These calibrations, though, are recognized to be problematic because δ 18 O in precipitation also depends on source conditions, water vapor advection and mixing, and storm trajectories [ Noone and Simmonds , 2002; Yoshimura et al , 2003; Treble et al , 2005b; Fischer and Sturm , 2006; Schneider and Noone , 2007], and these factors may be unrelated to the temperature and rainfall at the site of the terrestrial archive.…”