2000
DOI: 10.1103/physreve.61.204
|View full text |Cite
|
Sign up to set email alerts
|

Moment analysis of the probability distribution of different sandpile models

Abstract: We reconsider the moment analysis of the Bak-Tang-Wiesenfeld and the Manna sandpile model in two and three dimensions. In contrast to recently performed investigations our analysis turns out that the models are characterized by different scaling behavior, i.e., they belong to different universality classes.

Help me understand this report
View preprint versions

Search citation statements

Order By: Relevance

Paper Sections

Select...
2
1
1

Citation Types

15
84
0

Year Published

2000
2000
2015
2015

Publication Types

Select...
9
1

Relationship

0
10

Authors

Journals

citations
Cited by 80 publications
(99 citation statements)
references
References 30 publications
15
84
0
Order By: Relevance
“…The value of τ s for φ = 2 −12 is same as that of previously reported for DSM on RL (φ = 0) [35,40]. Note that the value of τ s of the BTW model (Dhar abelian sandpile model [26]) was also reported to be ≈ 1.11 though in the L → ∞ limit it is expected to be ≈ 1.29 [41][42][43]. There- fore the BTW type sandpile dynamics on RL remains unperturbed when performed on a lattice with additional N φ = 512 shortcuts corresponding to φ = 2 −12 on a lattice of size L = 1024.…”
Section: Probability Distributions and Conditional Expectation Valsupporting
confidence: 84%
“…The value of τ s for φ = 2 −12 is same as that of previously reported for DSM on RL (φ = 0) [35,40]. Note that the value of τ s of the BTW model (Dhar abelian sandpile model [26]) was also reported to be ≈ 1.11 though in the L → ∞ limit it is expected to be ≈ 1.29 [41][42][43]. There- fore the BTW type sandpile dynamics on RL remains unperturbed when performed on a lattice with additional N φ = 512 shortcuts corresponding to φ = 2 −12 on a lattice of size L = 1024.…”
Section: Probability Distributions and Conditional Expectation Valsupporting
confidence: 84%
“…In order to gain a better understanding of this general behavior, we have also looked at some other SOC models in this regard. Our preliminary results in the case of Manna model, which obeys FSS, show that the scaling exponent γ maintains a constant value close to 0.5 [31,33,34]. Such observation, as well as the similarities between the behavior of waves and type-α avalanches, makes us believe that the constancy of the γ exponent indicates that the scaling behavior of the corresponding relaxation process follows a simple power law behavior.…”
Section: Scaling Of Cpdf For Different Types Of Avalanchessupporting
confidence: 53%
“…However, numerical simulations using an extended set of critical exponents showed that deterministic and stochastic models exhibit different scaling properties and thus belong to different universality classes [26,27,28]. Further support for this result was obtained using multifractal analysis [29], moment analysis [30] as well as studies of sandpile models as closed systems [31,32,33]. The crossover between the two classes was also studied [34].…”
Section: Introductionmentioning
confidence: 82%