Monitor Height Ergonomics: A Comparison of Operating Room Video Display Terminals

Abstract

A surgeon's eyes should be positioned 1 meter (m) distant and no more than 15° below the top of an operating monitor (0.27 m). We sought to determine which operating room video display terminal can best accommodate ergonomically optimized gaze during surgery. Floor to eye height was measured for surgeons in seated, perched, and standing positions. These ranges were then compared to vertical displacement ranges for monitors measured from floor to top of the screen. Eye height was measured for standing (1.56–1.80 m), perched (1.40–1.65 m), and seated (1.10–1.32 m) positions. The minimum distance (min) between the floor and the top of the monitor and the vertical mobility range (VR) of the monitor were measured throughout a tertiary medical center including towers with boom arms (TcB) (min: 1.58 m, VR: 0.37 m), towers without booms (TsB) (min: 1.82 m, VR: 0.025 m), ceiling mounted booms (CMB) (min: 1.34 m:, VR: 1.04 m), and portable monitors (PM) (min: 1.73 m, VR: 0.04 m). The tangent of 15° declination was used to calculate a correction factor to determine the minimum optimal ergonomic display height. The correction factor was subtracted from the eye height at each position to determine the lowest target height and the highest target floor to eye distance for each position. Analysis of variance with least significant difference post hoc testing identified all minimum distances and vertical ranges to be statistically different (p < 0.001). Monitor vertical displacement varied between styles of carts. CMB video display terminal systems can accommodate standing, perched and the tallest seated surgeons. TcB, TsB and PM systems cannot adequately accommodate all standing, perched or seated surgeons.

Evaluation of 3D heads-up vitrectomy: outcomes of psychometric skills testing and surgeon satisfaction

“…Because surgical performance can be influenced by the surgeon’s comfort, heads-up surgery helps to enhance the procedure’s safety. Using TM, the vitreoretinal surgeon cannot move the head, shoulders and back during the operation, and neck and musculoskeletal fatigue, stiffness, mental and physical stress, and eyestrain are commonly reported after surgery [ 7 ]. The 3DM procedure is more comfortable because the surgeon can choose the most comfortable surgical position that allows some degree of movement [ 8 , 9 ].…”

Ergonomics and Musculoskeletal Health of the Surgeon

“…The main laparoscopic console should be in direct view of the surgeon or assistant to prevent rotation or poor posture to visualize equipment settings. 24,58 The monitor height should be in front of the operator and approximately 10 to 25 degrees below the horizontal plane of the eye with a downward gaze (►Fig. 1).…”

Safety, Performance, and Satisfaction Outcomes in the Operating Room: A Literature Review

“…Among ergonomic-related issues for surgeons, surgical table height, mayo stand height, and monitor position are key concerns, where the latter is the most significant factor impacting surgeon work performance and satisfaction (Marcos, Seitz, Bubb, Wichert, & Feussner, 2006; Matern & Koneczny, 2007). Through an ergonomic analysis of different screen configurations, Kelts, McMains, Chen, and Weitzel (2015) found that ceiling mounted booms provided the most flexible range of heights and were able to accommodate the ergonomic requirements for the surgeons in standing and perched positions as well as seating positions for tall surgeons (Kelts, McMains, Chen, & Weitzel, 2015). Additionally, positioning the monitor at eye-level reduced neck muscle strain among surgeons (Kelts et al, 2015).…”