Maintaining optimal telomere length throughout life limits cancer and enables healthy aging. Yet, it is unclear how the telomere length set point is determined. Telomeres in the house mouse, Mus musculus, are 2-4 times longer than human telomeres, limiting the use of the mouse as a model for telomere research. By introducing a single amino acid variation found in M. spretus into the helicase RTEL1 of M. musculus, we shortened its telomere length set point 2-3 times, implicating this variation in the dramatic difference in telomere length between the two mouse species. While the engineered mice are fertile and healthy, hepatocytes with short telomeres displayed reduced proliferation capacity. This 'telomouse' is a unique model for studying the implications of short telomeres in aging and cancer.