Multi-Atlas Library for Eliminating Normalization Failures in Non-Human Primates

Abstract

Introduction Current tools for automated skull stripping, normalization, and segmentation of non-human primate (NHP) brain MRI studies typically demonstrate high failure rates. Many of these failures are due to a poor initial estimate for the affine component of the transformation. The purpose of this study is to introduce a multi-atlas approach to overcome these limitations and drive the failure rate to near zero. Materials and Methods A library of study-specific templates (SST) spanning three Old World primate species (Macaca fascicularis, M. mulatta, Chlorocebus aethiops) was created using a previously described unbiased automated approach. Several modifications were introduced to the methodology to improve initial affine estimation at the study-specific template level, and at the individual subject level. These involve performing multiple separate normalizations to a multi-atlas library of templates and selecting the best performing template on the basis of a covariance similarity metric. This template was then used as an initialization for the affine component of subsequent skull stripping and normalization procedures. Normalization failure rate for SST generation and individual-subject segmentation on a set of 150 NHP was evaluated on the basis of visual inspection. Results The previous automated template creation procedure results in excellent skull stripping, segmentation, and atlas labeling across species. Failure rate at the individual-subject level was approximately 1%, however at the SST generation level it was 17%. Using the new multi-atlas approach, failure rate was further reduced to zero for both SST generation and individual subject processing. Conclusions We describe a multi-atlas library registration approach for driving normalization failures in NHP to zero. It is straightforward to implement, and can have application to a wide variety of existing tools, as well as in difficult populations including neonates and the elderly. This approach is also an important step towards developing fully automated high-throughput processing pipelines that are critical for future high volume multi-center NHP imaging studies for studies of drug abuse and brain health.

Blood‐Based Bioenergetic Profiling Reflects Differences in Brain Bioenergetics and Metabolism

“…Data for the frontal cortex were defined from a well-established nonhuman primate atlas, UNC-parcellation [ 45 ]. Complete methods for regional CMR generation with the two atlases can be found at Maldjian et al 2015 [ 46 ].…”

Morphometric analysis and neuroanatomical mapping of the zebrafish brain

“…Voxel-based morphometry is a powerful method for investigating anatomical brain abnormalities associated with human neurodevelopmental and psychiatric disorders. Although widely used in human neuroimaging studies, the application of VBM to vertebrate model organisms such as non-human primates and rodents has been limited by the accuracy of brain registration methods [57,58]. Advances in non-linear registration techniques and the construction of digital atlases have now allowed us to develop quantitative methods for voxel, deformation and volume-based analysis of zebrafish brains.…”

MonkeyCBP: A Toolbox for Connectivity-Based Parcellation of Monkey Brain

“…Ballanger et al applied MaS method to extract brain from T1weighted (T1w) MR images of crab-eating monkeys (Macaca fascicularis) (Ballanger et al, 2013), and they reported the first MaS dataset for NHP. Maldjian et al (2016) presented studyspecific atlases for rhesus, vervet, and cynomolgus monkeys. Brain extraction was used to transform the labels in the best performed atlas judged by image similarity; no quantitative evaluation was reported though.…”