Multi-dimensional Co-separation Analysis Reveals Protein–Protein Interactions Defining Plasma Lipoprotein Subspecies

Abstract

The distribution of circulating lipoprotein particles affects the risk for cardiovascular disease (CVD) in humans. Lipoproteins are historically defined by their density, with low-density lipoproteins positively and high-density lipoproteins (HDLs) negatively associated with CVD risk in large populations. However, these broad definitions tend to obscure the remarkable heterogeneity within each class. Evidence indicates that each class is composed of physically (size, density, charge) and compositionally (protein and lipid) distinct subclasses exhibiting unique functionalities and differing effects on disease. HDLs in particular contain upward of 85 proteins of widely varying function that are differentially distributed across a broad range of particle diameters. We hypothesized that the plasma lipoproteins, particularly HDL, represent a continuum of phospholipid platforms that facilitate specific protein-protein interactions. To test this idea, we separated normal human plasma using three techniques that exploit different lipoprotein physicochemical properties (gel filtration chromatography, ionic exchange chromatography, and preparative isoelectric focusing). We then tracked the co-separation of 76 lipid-associated proteins via mass spectrometry and applied a summed correlation analysis to identify protein pairs that may co- Lipoproteins are circulating emulsions of protein and lipid that play important roles, both positive and negative, in cardiovascular disease (CVD).1 Historically defined by their density as separated by ultracentrifugation, the major lipoprotein classes include the neutral lipid ester-rich very low-density and low-density lipoproteins (VLDLs and LDLs, respectively), which function to transport triglyceride and cholesterol from the liver to the peripheral tissues. Significant epidemiological evidence, in vitro studies, animal experiments, and human clinical trials have shown that high-LDL cholesterol is a bona fide causative factor in CVD (1). In contrast, protein-and phospholipid-rich high-density lipoproteins (HDLs) are thought to mediate the reverse transport of cholesterol from the periphery to the liver for catabolism and to perform anti-oxidative and anti-inflammatory functions (reviewed in Refs. 2 and 3). A host of human epidemiology and animal studies indicate that HDLs are atheroprotective (4). However, recent clinical trials of therapeutics that generically raise HDL, at least as measured by its cholesterol levels, have failed to confer the expected CVD protections (5-7).Although these traditional density-centric definitions have been used for nearly 40 years, accumulating evidence indicates that they are not particularly reflective of lipoprotein compositional and functional complexity. With respect to most physical traits (size, charge, lipid content, protein content, etc.), one can demonstrate significant heterogeneity within each density class. This suggests that particle subspecies exist with unique functions and effects on disease. For example, LDL can be resolved into large,...

Multiple apolipoprotein kinetics measured in human HDL by high-resolution/accurate mass parallel reaction monitoring

“…2A ). Our analysis confi rmed the presence of classical apolipoproteins, complement factors, fi brinogen, serpins, LCAT, and serum paraoxonase/arylesterase 1 (PON1), all of which were previously reported using other HDL isolation methods ( 35,36 ). The protein-specifi c sum-normalized spectral counts (per participant) estimated the relative proportion of protein abundances across the fi ve native gel size fractions.…”

Proteomic diversity of high density lipoproteins: our emerging understanding of its importance in lipid transport and beyond

“…In more recent work, we separated human plasma using three different separation techniques (gel fi ltration, ion exchange chromatography, and isoelectric focusing) and tracked protein elution patterns across them. The results show that numerous pairs of proteins tend to comigrate across the different separation techniques ( 83 ), suggesting the existence of discrete and stable subparticles. These reports indicate that, although some apolipoproteins and HDL-associated lipid remodeling factors undoubtedly exchange between HDL particles, others clearly do not.…”

Structure of HDL: Particle Subclasses and Molecular Components

“…Specific proteins may therefore be confined to distinct HDL subpopulations of distinct origin and function, which are differentially distributed across the HDL particle spectrum (Davidson et al 2009). The HDL fraction as a whole therefore appears to represent "a collection of individualised species with distinct functionalities that happen to have similar physicochemical properties" (Shah et al 2013) and are primarily defined by specific protein-protein interactions facilitated by the presence of phospholipid, rather than "a transient ensemble of randomly exchanging proteins" (Gordon et al 2013;Shah et al 2013). …”