This study deals with the efficacy of extracts of Sargassum natans and Sargassum fluitans, an invasive brown algae present in Guadeloupe, as novel and environmentally friendly corrosion inhibitors for iron in 1 mol L−1 hydrochloric acid solutions. Six different Sargassum extracts (SE) were obtained using Soxhlet extraction with ethyl acetate, acetone, and ethanol, respectively, as solvents; cold successive maceration with chloroform and methanol, respectively; and microwave-assisted extraction with water. Subsequent electrochemical analysis showed that extracts from ethanol and ethyl acetate exhibited remarkable inhibition efficiencies of, respectively, 72.6% and 70.2%, but the better one was the extract of the cold maceration from chloroform with an inhibition efficiency of 92.0%. These findings allow us to focus on the chloroform extract (SEd) in order to see the change happening during the corrosion process via SEM and EDX analyses. Also, NMR analysis was conducted to identify the main chemicals responsible for the anticorrosion effect. The successful demonstration of the corrosion inhibitor effectiveness of extracts of Sargassum natans and fluitans suggests a potentially valuable use for this invasive biomass. These encouraging results warrant further investigation to identify and elucidate the active inhibitors in these extracts to deepen our understanding of their mechanisms for corrosion prevention and potentially expand their utility as an environmentally conscious approach to corrosion control.