“…Secondly, studies performed at the regional/provincial level were all resourceful, including those on Northwest China [20], Yunnan [21], Guangdong [22][23][24], Jiangsu [25,26], Shanghai [27], Chongqing [28,29], and Xinjiang [30]. The factors found to have the greatest effect on carbon emissions were economic activity [20], investment [21], energy density [21,23,24,26], economic growth [23,24], export [21], population scale [24], energy efficiency [20], technical progress [24], industrial structure [22,23,26], and energy Sustainability 2019, 11,7008 3 of 20 mix [24,26]. For example, Dong et al [21] analyzed the energy-related carbon emissions of five provinces in Northwest China from 1995 to 2012 (Shaanxi, Ningxia, Qinghai, Gansu, and Xinjiang) and found that the effect of economic activity produced a significant impact on increased carbon emission.…”