Multiple Conceptualizations of Small Business Web Use and Benefit*

Abstract

Small businesses play an important role in the U.S. economy and there is anecdotal evidence that use of the Web is beneficial to such businesses. There is, however, little systematic analysis of the conditions that lead to successful use of and thereby benefits from the Web for small businesses. Based on the innovation adoption, organizations, and information systems (IS) implementation literature, we identify a set of variables that are related to adoption, use, and benefits of information technology (IT), with particular emphasis on small businesses. These variables are reflective of an organization's contextual characteristics, its IT infrastructure, Web use, and Web benefits. Since the extant research does not suggest a single theoretical model for Web use and benefits in the context of small businesses, we adopt a modeling approach and explore the relationships between "context-IT-use-benefit" (CIUB) through three models-partial-mediator, reduced partial-mediator, and mediator. These models posit that the extent of Web use by small businesses and the associated benefits are driven by organizations' contextual characteristics and their IT infrastructure. They differ in the endogeneity/exogeneity of the extent of IT sophistication, and in the direct/mediated effects of organizational context. We examine whether the relationships between variables identified in the literature * The names are arranged in alphabetical order. All authors have contributed equally in the development of this manuscript. This research was partially supported by a grant from the Center for Study of Western Hemispheric Trade, University of Texas, El Paso. † Corresponding author. 468Multiple Conceptualizations of Small Business Web Use and Benefit hold within the context of these models using two samples of small businesses with national coverage, including various sizes, and representing several industry sectors. The results show that the evidence for patterns of relationships is similar across the two independent samples for two of these models. We highlight the relationships within the reduced partial-mediator and mediator models for which conclusive evidence are given by both samples. Implications for small business managers and providers of Web-based technologies are discussed.

Understanding the Antecedents of Knowledge Sharing: An Organizational Justice Perspective

“…The survey yielded 220 usable responses for a response rate of 5.5%, which is a limitation of the study. Other published surveys, however, have had a similar response rate (Pflughoeft, Ramamurthy, Soofi, Yasai-Ardekani, & Zahedi, 2003).There can be several reasons for the low response rate in the current study. First, the length of the instrument might have dissuaded responses.…”

Achieving advantages from business-to-business electronic commerce: an empirical validation of an integrative framework

“…Indeed, EC capability, which encompasses information use and transactional use of EC (as well as customisation and back-end integration), exhibits a positive relationship with firm performance (Zhu, 2004). Findings from Pflughoeft et al (2003) suggest that the use of the web for e-commerce (transactional use) by small businesses is related to both strategic benefits (expressed in terms of market expansion, increasing sales, and improving customer bases) and operational efficiencies (such as reductions in operating costs, productivity, speed of conducting business activities, ability of employees to work away from the office, and the firm's ability to meet customers' needs). Additionally, according to theses authors, use of web for information search (information use) is linked to operational efficiencies.…”

“…Findings from these studies have shown that EC adoption and use by organisations can generate various advantages (Pflughoeft et al, 2003;Pires and Aisbett, 2003). EC usage has a significant impact on business performance Merono-Cerdan and Soto-Acosta, 2005;Ramamurthy and Premkumar, 1995;Shin, 2004;Yao et al, 2002;Wade et al, 2004;Zhu and Kraemer, 2005).…”

E-commerce applications in the tourism industry: A Tanzania case study

“…For the case in which the relationships between observed indicators and constructs are uncertain or when constructs are new, Yoon (2002) and Pflughoet et al (2003) recommended an EFA before a CFA to identify the underlying constructs and investigate the relationships between indicators.…”